I understand that one of the requirements for the tumbleweed badge is that a question has no upvotes, but why? I can see it as being a kind of consolation badge for those that don't get their questions answered, but surely if people upvote it (therefore showing it as a good question) and it still gets no answers or comments then that's arguably more frustrating!
It seems with the current system that users are punished by not getting the badge for asking a potentially better question, which seems a bit strange to me.