Should a user have to add a comment when they vote to close
I've asked questions before, and someone has come along and marked it for close, despite others attempting to answer it, and various other participation.
The problem here is that I have no idea why they wanted to close the question. Some people leave a comment, but most people make no effort. A lot of the time simply clarifying the question further would satisfy the people who think the question does not belong somewhere ( when actually it does, it was jsut worded ina way they didn't 'get' ).
It's also problematic because if users keep asking questions, make the same mistake over and over again, and get their questions closed, they're going to keep making that mistake, as there's no room for learning any bad behaviour on what closes a question.