Consolation badges for hitting the reputation cap hard
Possibly silly, but why not have an overachiever badge?
Overachiever: Received X upvotes, all after hitting the reputation cap
(full disclosure, there's no way I'd qualify for this badge for any non-trivial value for X)
Or, Andrew's version which I like better
Overachiever: Received X upvotes on at least Y posts, all after hitting the reputation cap
Which of course would prevent users from getting the badge for one good answer on a popular question.
I'd also be interested in hearing Bronze, Silver, and Gold naming possibilities anyone might have.
This was requested here, and was oddly marked as status complete with the advent of the Mortarboard, Epic and Legendary badges, even though those badges have nothing to do with votes over the cap.