What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 130 Stack Exchange communities.

Is there a feature that lets people vote to move a question to another Stack Exchange site?

I am asking this because I asked a question on SO and some members said that you should ask this question in programmers.stackexchange.com and then they closed the question.

I was thinking that if I did a mistake to ask a question that did not belong to SO but to another sister sites of it, it would be more helpful if people could help me move the question there instead of closing it. (For example they could click a move to site button and select a site name and if 4 people select the same site, the question is closed but there's a move button available to the owner that he can use to move his question there)

Edit:

It seems that SO has thought of everything.I salute you, SO programmers :)) but it seems that people are more eager on closing an off topic question as fast as possible rather than helping the questioner to find his answer (even in another site )

share|improve this question
    
There are thousands of questions posted every day. I'm not sure users who can close vote always have time to be personal about finding the best place for a question. They can vote and leave a comment, but commenting is of their own volition. –  simchona Feb 22 '12 at 15:14
    
update the question has been migrated to Code Review: codereview.stackexchange.com/questions/9271/… –  gnat Feb 22 '12 at 15:14
    
Well I should confess that all of these discussions helped me to understand more about the community of SO and stackexchange and the synergy it can offer and I also find another great sites of stackexchange family (codereview).Thank you all for bearing with me :)) –  Beatles1692 Feb 22 '12 at 17:09

4 Answers 4

up vote 8 down vote accepted

If you close a question you can select as reason that it is offtopic (and you can select one of the other sites). As BoltClock commented this is also possible with a flag.

If you move a question, it will still be closed in the site it is offtopic, that's why it's behind that feature I guess.

enter image description here

Of course, it will not be moved if users (closers that is) do not agree on the close reason.

share|improve this answer
2  
In fact, even if you don't have the rep to vote to close, flagging with "doesn't belong here" and choosing "off topic" will lead you to the same set of choices, except as a flag. –  BoltClock's a Unicorn Feb 22 '12 at 15:00
    
It's worth noting that questions can be moved like this only to a limited set of SE sites. For example, the move of that question to codereview.SE had to be done by a mod. –  svick Feb 22 '12 at 16:13
    
Adding to what @svick said, if the site isn't on one of the available migration paths, you'll have to flag to ask a mod to do it. –  BoltClock's a Unicorn Feb 22 '12 at 17:20

but it seems that people are more eager on closing an off topic question as fast as possible rather than helping the questioner to find his answer (even in another site )

There is nothing wrong with this. We want off topic questions, unconstructive questions, etc, closed because we do not want the site to rot. People left comments directing you to Programmers, which was a bad suggestion, and I left a comment suggesting Code Review. (Note: Code Review is still in beta, and it is not a migration option when voting.)

With those comments, you could have followed the links, read the "About" and the "FAQ," and then determined if the site was indeed a good fit. Frankly, I would prefer that you to have to do this instead of having the code migrated by vote, because people who don't know the target sites tend to have poor judgment, and then your question gets closed twice, which would presumably not enhance your user experience. Nevertheless, the fact that the system allows migration-by-vote is a courtesy, not an obligation, and it requires a majority vote. (Super-majority in the case of some sites, not sure if it applies to all.)

share|improve this answer
    
Thanks a lot .The question is on the right site due to your help. –  Beatles1692 Feb 22 '12 at 15:46

It seems that Stack Overflow has thought of everything. I salute you, Stack Exchange programmers, but it seems that people are more eager on closing an off topic question as fast as possible rather than helping the questioner to find his answer (even in another site).

There are some points to consider about that:

  • Migrating a question requires the majority of the votes (which means 4 votes out of 5, if I recall that exactly).
  • Even in the case the question gets the necessary votes to be migrated, it is not migrated if the question is not using tags the receiving site is not using.
  • The first rule of migrating is, "don't migrate crap"; with this, I don't mean your question was a bad question, but that probably users avoid migrating questions for which they are not 100% sure. I can be sure about off-topic questions for a site I visit more often than another, but I am not sure at the same level for a site I have never visited.
  • Helping the OP to find the right home for an OP's answer is not that easy. The fact a user is active on a Stack Exchange site doesn't mean the same user is active on related sites. For example, I am active more on Drupal Answers, and sometimes on Stack Overflow; if I were asked for which site a question would be a better suit, I would not probably be able to correctly reply in most of the cases, especially because there are some sites I have never been in, that are related to programming, or code, in some way.
  • Even in the case users could be able to understand which is a better site for the question, there is still to see if there is already similar question your question is duplicating. A user that happens to be active on Stack Overflow, and the other site, can know when there is already a too similar asked question; that cannot be said for every user who votes to close a question.
share|improve this answer

When voting to close, users have the option of voting to migrate a question to another site. It requires that all of the users agree on this, however. If you want to move your question, flag it and ask a mod to do so. Note that the other site may still vote to close your question if it's not a good fit.

share|improve this answer
1  
Moderators of a site generally consult the moderators of the site which would receive the question; as this is done in the moderators' chat room, this is something not visible to the other users. The risk of a closed question on the receiving site should be mitigated. –  kiamlaluno Feb 22 '12 at 15:19

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .