What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 127 Stack Exchange communities.

Of the 3797 badges present in the data dump, only 2982 were issued with the creation date of 2008-09-23. Since the beta badges were issued, people have been earning them in trickles.

Should the beta badge awarding be locked?

share|improve this question
6  
love the "justice" tag :) –  Blorgbeard Jun 28 '09 at 11:03
1  
Thanks. I was really trying to be funny here, but it has not gone done well with some SOpedians... –  Stu Thompson Jun 28 '09 at 12:11
    
Sorry was this humor? Someone described humor as being able to laugh at other people's misfortune. I now no longer have my prized Beta badge. Someone is probably laughing about that, but it's not me. –  Scott Ferguson Sep 9 '09 at 0:34
2  
Yes, humor. No, I'm not laughing at your 'misfortune', but rather having fun with the language in both my question and answer posts. Besides, you didn't deserve a beta badge! (As noted, you never posted a question or answer during the beta.) So, stop your bitching and move on. –  Stu Thompson Sep 9 '09 at 20:03
add comment

5 Answers

up vote 17 down vote accepted

Yes! The sanctity of the Beta Badge is sullied! Stop this badge inflation now!

An example user 155. He didn't rank a beta badge until very recent activity (mid-June), when he was awarded a beta badge!

Sign up in early September, answer almost nothing...leave for six months, and when you return to a production site and start posting again, you still get the Beta badge!

This means that over 1000 badges have been awarded to folks who where not active enough during the beta period to earn one, like us Original Hardcore 2982 SOpedians.

2982 forever!

share|improve this answer
4  
I agree totally. If you signed up during the beta and did nothing, then you did not help with the beta at all and shouldn't get the badge! 2982 for life. –  Thomas Owens Jun 28 '09 at 12:41
5  
I read this as "Boohoo! Someone got a meaningless arrangement of electrons in computer that I got too. I am offended. Please send out all badges as hard copy certificates in future. My resume sucks without them." Just kidding ;) I don't have a beta badge and won't ever get one. Cherish yours and know that to you, it means something. –  Jeff Yates Jul 27 '09 at 14:06
6  
@Jeff Yates: You don't have a Beta Badge? Loser!!! To comfort myself against this topics injustice, I went down to my local statue artisans and had them make me up a 420g silver medallion with the words 'Stack Overflow' and 'Original 2982 Forever' around the rim, a big 'BETA' in the center, purple velvet ribbon, and an LCD display of my current SO flair on the back. It beeps every time some reads my profile. I sleep with it every night. Mmmmm...... –  Stu Thompson Jul 27 '09 at 17:35
7  
that's not weird at all. –  Jeff Atwood Aug 19 '09 at 11:56
    
@StuThompson yes, yes I can quite believe you do have a beeping medallion, that you sleep with and keeps you awake all night, the chronic sleep deprivation would explain much ;) hahahahha hm, glad u got yr cyber badge, fixed in concrete and all that.. congrats, pat on the back and all... cough cough –  user223277 Jul 17 '13 at 15:39
add comment

criteria for Stack Overflow / Super User / Server Fault beta badges

  • member before private beta ended
  • earned 3 bronze badges on or before 9-15-2008 (date private beta ended)

(please note, these rules do NOT apply to SE 2.0 beta badges)

I don't really have a problem with users earning it later. They did sign up during the beta.

I had a change of heart on this, and ruled out earning the beta badge after the beta period is over, as it did seem a little unfair to those who were really active during the beta. I made adjustments on SO and SF to reflect that.

share|improve this answer
6  
They did sign up during the beta, but they didn't "Actively participated in the Stack Overflow private beta." like it says on the badge page stackoverflow.com/badges/30/beta –  Brad Gilbert Jun 29 '09 at 3:45
17  
Well, they did test the sign up... –  toast Jul 2 '09 at 18:45
    
What about Superuser, nobody has a badge there yet, although they would be eligible according to this? –  Peter Smit Jul 27 '09 at 14:00
5  
The unpredictable god has spoken! –  Ladybug Killer Aug 19 '09 at 12:00
2  
Oh so that's what happened with all those beta badges. –  Eric Aug 19 '09 at 12:07
1  
+1 for the change of heart –  Jonik Aug 19 '09 at 12:14
    
Couldn't you have a change of heart, like, about 2 hours later? just asked the first question on Super User :-P –  Chris Jester-Young Aug 19 '09 at 13:27
2  
I do listen, eventually. Sometimes. Depending on the phase of the moon. And what these Tarot cards tell me to do. –  Jeff Atwood Aug 19 '09 at 13:28
1  
So if we manage to rig your tarot cards... –  Greg Aug 19 '09 at 14:04
2  
There are now 2,618 beta badges awarded on SO, about 300 less than Stu said were awarded when the site went public. Were these accounts that were pruned for lack of activity? Or was the original number incorrect? –  Kyle Cronin Aug 19 '09 at 14:27
    
@Kyle: Assuming no answer from Jeff, I'll have a look at the next dump and see where the discrepancy comes from. –  Stu Thompson Aug 29 '09 at 21:13
    
Interesting: as of 31 Aug, there are still only 2618 Beta badges. My guess is that the algorithm that awarded them initially with a date of '2008-09-23' (and many more subsequently with later dates) is different in some small way from the new, restrictive algorithm. The new group is ~42% of all beta period sign ups. –  Stu Thompson Sep 2 '09 at 21:42
1  
Are the requirements still the same on SE sites? I had three bronze badges on gamedev before the public beta began, and I didn't get Beta. Wondering if I should report it. –  mmyers Jul 23 '10 at 17:35
    
@mmyers no, the requirements are a bit more strict now. –  Jeff Atwood Jul 23 '10 at 18:55
5  
@Jeff. Maybe you should edit your answer. To reflect the stricter requirements. At least say its not the three bronze badge rule –  Some Helpful Commenter Dec 7 '10 at 21:50
add comment

I don't really mind too much about them getting beta badges, but if that is the case then the text that is associated with the beta badge, should really be changed from

Actively participated in the Stack Overflow private beta.

to

Managed to get an Account during the private beta, and also, at some point, participated.

share|improve this answer
add comment

First, I think the Beta badge will keep to be useful in the future. When Stack Overflow 2.0 with nifty HTML5 and Web 3.0 social, semantic and 3D features will be beta-tested, the ones willing to brave the beta version instead of the safe, known SO 1.0 as you know it today will deserve a beta badge.

Second, Stu's answer to me sounds a bit like whining. So what if the guy answered only a few questions instead of racking up 000's of points? If he posted at least one answer during the beta period, he did do something, and I'd say he deserves a badge.

share|improve this answer
2  
It is comedy, really. I'm really not that fussed about it. –  Stu Thompson Jun 28 '09 at 9:37
1  
Seriously! How can you take "The sanctity of the Beta Badge is sullied!" credibly? –  Stu Thompson Jun 28 '09 at 9:38
1  
Comedy?! Haven't you heard? The internet is serious business! –  Greg Aug 19 '09 at 14:05
    
@Stu Thompson: Comedy? Funny, the other night I just watched a re-run of Good Morning Vietnam. Remember that part where Robin Williams character is taken off the air, and replaced by his boss?"Listen, Frenchy, let me ask you something. Do you like good food? "Oh, but of course. Uh, the French love good food." Well, then, I guess that would make you an "Eatie Gourmet." "Oh, ho, ho, ho, Lieutenant Steve." - Oh, Frenchy. - "Oh, ho, ho, Lieutenant Steve." ... –  Scott Ferguson Sep 9 '09 at 0:50
    
The Sanctity of the Beta Badge prevents me from responding to this. –  Stu Thompson Sep 9 '09 at 20:16
add comment

I guess it is up to Jeff, but I miss my badge.

It kind of was the only badge I cared for. I read a lot of stuff related to this site, have listen to every podcast, but I have only posted some Spolsky-question (very obvious and possibly a source for hits from Google) that my students often ask me. I think the point is that I feel a little sad to not be recognized as a long time member anymore (very low reputation).

Boohoo, I want be with the cool kids again.

share|improve this answer
    
When you are crying yourself to sleep tonight over this great loss, you can think of me!!! (And meticulously plot my demise as you peacefully drift off into...) –  Stu Thompson Sep 7 '09 at 11:48
2  
I couldn't agree more P-A. Rightly or wrongly I felt part of the Beta community. I answered questions, and asked questions (starting from Sep 18, 08). I did voting. I had the BETA badge for nearly a year, and I wore it with pride. Then it just arbitrarily disappears. Jeff, you know very well that people were going to have an affinity to the badge system, that's why you put it in. To have such a special badge for so long, then have it taken away leaves people feeling worthless. –  Scott Ferguson Sep 9 '09 at 0:02
1  
Take it easy Stu. I felt wronged (still do). I complained. It did no good. Such is life. I'm over it. Life goes on. Have a nice day. –  Scott Ferguson Sep 10 '09 at 4:41
    
@Stu I have really hard time understanding you attitude in this question. I think both Scott and I has quite sober and calm reaction. Non of us demands the badge and both us seems to be around a quite bit from time to time and just simple enjoyed to able to show that off. We are more of long time users then extremely active ones, in my case I read then listen more then I actively post stuff, and now Jeff has decided that he wants to reword the people that was more active in the beta. Fair enough, we accept that. We only raised the points that we missed our badges. –  P-A Sep 10 '09 at 8:02
    
@P-A: Scott's reaction was sober? He spammed this entire question with angry comments. (Some have since deleted.) "Das Leben ist kein Ponyhof", as they say. –  Stu Thompson Sep 14 '09 at 10:35
    
I am sorry if you feel that I did not treat you fair. And I am also the first to admit that I have not read every comment in this question so maybe you are right too. But that was not may point, my point was that I do not really understand your reaction. But I think it is time to put that behind us now. I really like stackoverflow and my guess is that you do that too and think that is enough for now, so lets move on to more important issues. –  P-A Sep 15 '09 at 21:02
add comment

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .