What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 134 Stack Exchange communities.

I asked a question that within 5 minutes received 1 up vote and 7 down votes.

What was so bad about this question? I wanted to get the argument for Python, so I could see the other side of the story. Was it just the wording, or is something else terribly wrong? (no, there were no comments in the first 5 minutes before I deleted the question.)

What makes Python better than Node.JS?

So I do a Google search Python vs Node.JS, and I found a good summary of what makes Node.JS better:

  1. It's built to handle asynchronous I/O from the ground up. Other environments have async. I/O features, but Node's the first environment where it's really pervasive. In most environments you'll find only limited pieces available in async. flavors, but in Node everything (or nearly everything) is async.-only.

    ...

  2. It's "just JavaScript." ... Staying in a single language feels faster.

  3. It's new, so it has the benefit of being able to learn from previous languages' and environments' mistakes ... hasn't had time to accumulate the cruft other languages/environments have.

I already use and like Node.JS, but I wanted to get a comparison that is biased towards Python. What upsides would there be to introducing Python into a team that is currently unfamiliar?

I'm thinking

  • More widespread support
  • Less code to write for many operations
  • More complete library

When it comes to a Web Development, is there anything else I should know?

P.S. I love the streaming updates of my question score. :) Though I would suggest that we encourage more commenting during a rain of down-votes.

share|improve this question
6  
From the title "What makes A better than B" is one of those questions which sound pretty much "Not Constructive". The question itself seems to invite a discussion as well, which is not really what SO is for. That might have invited the downvotes. –  Bart May 21 '12 at 14:11
    
Maybe something like, "please summarize the argument for Python over Node.JS"? or is this question just not going to fly? –  George Bailey May 21 '12 at 14:12
6  
No matter how well intended and how much you try to restrict the question from evolving into a discussion, it is very likely going to end up being one. It's one of those situations where, no matter how good you make your question, it's difficult to have it fit in with this particular Q&A IMHO. –  Bart May 21 '12 at 14:16
1  
    
+1 for being polite and curious. :) –  sarnold May 21 '12 at 23:12

2 Answers 2

up vote 9 down vote accepted

When it comes to a Web Development, is there anything else I should know?

This makes the question open-ended and a "list of" question which is not constructive/not a real question. There's a whole load of stuff you should know, but having a list of this stuff doesn't make the internet a better place and there's no one thing that you particularly need to know more than any other thing.

share|improve this answer

This Stackoverflow Blog Post by Jeff Atwood helps break it down where I can understand.

If I understand correctly, my question was not specific enough, and too much akin to "tables vs divs" or "to semicolon or not to semicolon".

Although the question in question is more credible, there are still a lot of variables/details making one language different from the other, and a constructive question would need to be much more specific.

share|improve this answer

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .