What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 128 Stack Exchange communities.

I asked a question that turned out to have multiple correct answers. How do I pick between them to determine which to accept?

Edit: All of the answers were different. They were not the same answer given multiple times. Here is the question.

share|improve this question

migrated from stackoverflow.com Aug 10 '09 at 7:32

This question came from our site for professional and enthusiast programmers.

2  
Were the answers different, but all correct? Or the same answer submitted at different times? –  Bill the Lizard Oct 24 '08 at 19:32
    
All of the answers were all different. –  Dan Goldstein Oct 24 '08 at 19:36
    
Yes, but only one of them is correct. Now all you need to do is find out which one - and then accept it ;-) –  Treb Oct 24 '08 at 19:46
    
Why bother ask such question when you don't accept any answer for it. –  Elist Jul 25 '13 at 15:01

7 Answers 7

First of all, vote! The voting buttons suggest:

  • Upvote = Answer is useful
  • Downvote = Answer is not useful

Use them accordingly.

Secondly, there are no "shared first places" when it comes to accepting answers. So, pick the one that was most useful/helpful to you. This may differ from the criteria you laid out when asking the question. It's your choice.

Finally, if you feel like you still owe someone a reward for not picking their answer, you can always issue a bounty.

share|improve this answer

If the answers are different, but all correct, I would upvote all of the correct answers, and accept the one that I actually use.

If the answers are all the same, but came in at different times, I would accept the one that came in first, unless one answer was more clear or went into greater detail.

share|improve this answer
    
As suggested in another post, edit the accepted answer to include each of the others and give credit to the original authors. That way when others find the page when searching on Google they get a good overview of the possible solutions. –  Paul Alexander Jun 23 '09 at 17:47
    
@Paul: In the case of duplicate answers I certainly wouldn't bother. In the case of different but still correct answers, I still wouldn't bother. Treb's answer to this question is right there, why add it to this answer? –  Bill the Lizard Jun 23 '09 at 18:05

I would accept the answer that came in first. If you hover over the relative, time, it will show actual time, down to the second, to resolve any disputes when they both say "3 hours ago".

share|improve this answer
    
I almost voted this down because I disagree with it...then I saw it wasn't wiki'd. :) –  Thomas Owens Oct 24 '08 at 19:32

Accept the answer that came in first unless someone else has been more thorough in their explanation of the solution to the question presented.

share|improve this answer

Up-vote all answers that apply. Eventually, community will kick in and someone will edit the answer with higher number of votes (hopefully more complete one) to include all the details. And that's your winner.

share|improve this answer

That which most precisely and concisely answer your question. If you can't decide, accept the fastest answer.

share|improve this answer

Pick the one that is better because it is

  • contains more source code
  • contains shorter source code
  • explains things in a simpler way
  • explains things in a more expilicit way
  • is written funnier
  • is written more seriously...

...or whatever criteria appeals to you that distinguishes one answer from the other. So far I have seen quite a lot of questions with similar answers, but there were always differences, and I would always have been able to find some tiny thing to help me pick one of them as my preferred answer.

share|improve this answer

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .