What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 127 Stack Exchange communities.

My question on Cross Validated didn't attract any answers yet and it was mentioned by two senior members there (one of which was in meta) that it might be better on Stack Overflow. Could I have opinions on whether that is a good idea ?

share|improve this question
add comment

2 Answers

up vote 3 down vote accepted

First, your goal is to run tasks on your computer for the purpose of crunching some numbers. You're not building software that will be used by anyone else. Thus, this seems to me to be a Stats problem and not necessarily a StackOverflow problem. It is borderline, and if your question were just limited to the coding, it could be on topic... maybe.

However, in the meta question, you're asking specifically about buying hardware. This would definitely be off topic on StackOverflow and would more than likely be considered not constructive on any other StackExchange site, since it could be construed as a shopping question.

However, with some editing to focus the question on the topic of the hardware's effect on the speed of your results, asking more specific questions and being sure not to ask for recommendations or suggestions, this could be on topic on Superuser.

From slhck in the Superuser Chat Room:

"Right now it focuses too much on programming and data structures and whatnot. However, if it doesn't end up as a shopping recommendation asking for which hardware to buy, it's fine. If you could help the OP nudge their question towards asking what kind of hardware resources are needed for these tasks, that'd be on-topic."

"Like, are these operations CPU intensive or memory intensive, and how they could find out"

share|improve this answer
    
Thank you. So, perhaps I can rephrase the question to query the effect of different aspects of hardware (CPU clock speed, cache size, number of cores) on the particular type of lower-level (ie optimisation) routines that are being performed in the code I am executing, and post that on superuser ? –  Joe King Jun 23 '12 at 19:33
    
Hi Joe, I asked in the Superuser chat room for you (since you don't yet have enough rep to chat there), and I included the response above. It pretty much confirms my suggestion. Just make sure you're focusing on the problem (what can I do to improve my hardware for speed) and less on shopping questions or recommendations. Good luck! –  jmort253 Jun 23 '12 at 19:52
    
As jmort253 already mentioned, that would be fine. I'm not too sure most Super Users have experience with statistical programming in R, so it might not be necessary to include your actual code. Just let us know what the principles behind that computation are :) @JoeKing –  slhck Jun 23 '12 at 19:55
1  
@jmort253 thank you very much for doing that :) –  Joe King Jun 23 '12 at 20:10
add comment

I'm going to pick a small nit with @jmort253's answer, but mostly we agree.

The hardware piece of the question is certainly off topic on SO, but the other piece of the question is most certainly not a "stats" question, in that it isn't about the theory. Rather it is a performance related question about a statistical programming language.

However, it is definitely not the case that the only programming questions that are on topic at SO involve "creating software for other people to use". If that were the case, basically every question with the [r] tag (13000+) would be off topic (not to mention Matlab!).

That said, the first half of your question at Cross Validated is probably too broad as currently written to be a good SO question. If you had tried a specific method/technique to speed up your code and it wasn't working, that would be more on topic. As it stands, it would probably simply elicit a variety of recommendations, which isn't the sort of thing we're looking for on SO.

But I also think that the folks active in the [r] tag at SO are likely to contain the people who are most likely to be of some help. It looks like you don't have enough rep to chat there either, so I will post a link to your CV question there and ask if people would be willing to point you in the right direction, at the very least with a comment.

Finally, you might also find people who could help with this kind of problem on the R mixed model mailing list.

share|improve this answer
add comment

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .