After using the Low Quality Posts review queue for a little while, I've noticed a trend that when someone doesn't know the answer they take a wild stab and post it as the answer. What action should I take in the tool for this behavior? I'm choosing Not Sure for now, since obviously I'm not sure what to do.
What is meta?
- Any Stack Exchange user can ask a question
- The community provides support, votes on ideas, and reports bugs
- Your voice helps shape the way Stack Exchange operates
As said, it would be cool to see some examples but in general, an answer being a "Stab in the dark" alone shouldn't warrant any review action. The way to deal with incorrect answers is downvoting, not deleting.
After all, "stab in the dark" is a subjective category, and we don't know for certain how the answer came about. Maybe it was just worded by a very knowledgeable user with poor writing abilities.
So if you want to vote to delete, look whether the answer has other, legitimate problems - for example, whether it consists of a link only, or should be a comment.
If those criteria don't apply, downvote if you feel it's a blatantly incorrect answer; otherwise, move on.
If the "stab in the dark" explains how to try the suggested solution, it is an answer.
If it only asks "have you tried [this]" or "Try [this]", where [this] is a topic, not a solution, it is a comment.
There are grey areas though, of course, especially depending upon how the question asks for solutions.