What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 131 Stack Exchange communities.

Ok so I want to ask "Where can I find an MSI for installing Eclipse," since eclipse only seems to distribute it as a tarball/zip of compiled binaries. I'm not sure which site to ask it on. Here's my justification for each:

  • Stackoverflow - An IDE is used for programming, therefore its a programming question
  • Serverfault - A systemadministrator for a company that writes java apps on windows machines might want to use or provide to his users eclipse MSIs
  • Super User - It't not directly programming related and not directly server related.

Being I've had a similar question closed on serverfault because it was not considered programing related, I figured, let me ask where to ask.

Edit: I asked the question poorly. reworded it.

share|improve this question

4 Answers 4

I don't understand why this question has to be asked at all.

Maybe I'm just not familiar enough with Eclipse, but "where do I download an installer for Eclipse" seems to be a question of zero value, to me.

Where do you download Visual Studio? TextMate?

That's not about programming, it's a basic Internet 101 question.

share|improve this answer
5  
I think he's just confused by the fact that eclipse comes as zip file and there is no need to "install" it. Yes, a basic question, but in this day and age of installers for everything you can see how a new user might be confused. –  zdan Aug 16 '09 at 6:12
1  
@JeffAtwood I want an MSI. I am more than capable of installing a zip file. When I encounter this problem with small OSS projects, I usually write an MSI and give it to the author to include in the source project. Most eclipse distros are distributed via zip files. However some, Apache Directory Studio realize the importance (at least in my mind) of having a proper installer for your software. –  Justin Dearing Aug 16 '09 at 11:51
6  
This seems pretty clear-cut then, as it's not really a question about Eclipse... If you need an MSI for some sort of automated deployment thing, ask on SF; if you just don't like manually creating directories and unzipping files, SU; if you need help making the MSI, SO. –  Shog9 Aug 16 '09 at 17:07
    
@Shog9 FTW! +1. –  Randolpho Apr 13 '10 at 13:49

Post it on StackOverflow.

There are a lot of IDE questions there.

share|improve this answer
    
The reason for many IDE questions on stackoverflow probably has more to do with Stackoverflow being the first site up, than it being the best place to ask these questions now. As a matter of fact, I expect that as membership grows and rules become more clearly defined for what category of questions go where for edge cases, that contributors with too much time on their hands will go looking for miscatagorized questions and move them between sites. In other words, I'm hoping for a wikipedia like cabal of contributors to form. –  Justin Dearing Aug 16 '09 at 4:25

sudo apt-get install eclipse or sudo pacman -Sy eclipse ;) (See win-get, that has an Eclipse entry [Broken download]. Also see WPKG.)


I think that this is more of a question for Super User.

It's not programming related per sé. If it were how to deploy Eclipse across several computers easily, it might be Server Fault worthy.

I mean, it's about installing the application, not about how to setup the programming environment (which would be OK in SO, IMHO), or how to build from source.

share|improve this answer

If it is a server software, then serverfault, if it is a development tool like Eclipse, then Stack Overflow. If it is more of an end user utility, then probably SuperUser

share|improve this answer
    
That seems a bit like repeating obvious points on an old question just to put the link to your site, you know? –  Gnoupi Apr 13 '10 at 13:52
    
Also, you put "game" for Super User. You deserve my -1. –  Gnoupi Apr 13 '10 at 13:53
    
The distinction between server-side, development tool or end-user tool was never made. There is a lot of open source out there, each one packaged for a difference audience. StackOverflow and related sites is 0.2% of our traffic so I kind of have to chuckle at your suggestion, but anyways just to avoid any doubt, I removed the reference to Bitnami. –  Daniel Lopez Apr 13 '10 at 14:00
    
@Daniel - when you know the purpose of each of these sites, it was a bit stating the obvious: "Server related to SF, programming related to SO, end user to SU". This is why I said that, moreover with including your link in it. Have a nice chuckling. –  Gnoupi Apr 13 '10 at 14:09
    
Maybe I didn't express myself clearly. Justin was asking where it would be more appropriate to post a question about an MSI for a particular piece of software. In the question he suggested it could be potentially posted to any of the three sites (for example because an admin may want to distribute those MSIs, hence it may be a serverfault question). My suggestion was to look at it from the angle of not how the software being packaged in an MSI may be used by different people but of the category of the software itself. In the Eclipse particular case, it is a development tool so it belongs to SO –  Daniel Lopez Apr 13 '10 at 14:17
    
@Daniel - And this view is too simple, because in the case of Eclipse, Super User is correct as well. –  Gnoupi Apr 13 '10 at 14:53

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .