What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 134 Stack Exchange communities.

Ever since we got the ability to format comments, I have abused it mercilessly. I put quick code snippets in there all of the time. And I find myself often highlighting a word or two and hitting Ctrl+K, and then quickly mutter, "Ah, dammit," since it didn't do anything.

Can we please have formatting keyboard shortcuts on comments? I promise to make waffles.

Update: Kip made a timely edit of this post (didn't show up in my search, dammit) where this was declined, but there's a GreaseMonkey script. However, my waffle offer still stands.

share|improve this question
2  
What kind of waffles? –  random Aug 16 '09 at 4:54
2  
Homemade Belgian. With pure maple syrup. You can choose place of origin: Canadia, Vermont, or Upstate New York. –  Eric Aug 16 '09 at 4:56
    
Random waffles, of course. :) (Sorry, couldn't resist.) –  John Rudy Aug 16 '09 at 4:56
1  
Eric, I've always wanted this!!!! –  Adel Sep 5 '12 at 15:04

5 Answers 5

Personally, since formatting was added to the comment feature, I think it's been overused in general. Once upon a time (pre-formatting), I thought it would be nice, maybe even helpful (eg, it might make comments easier to read).

I found the exact opposite once it was implemented and people were using it. I've used it a few times myself, but I'm worried that anything which makes it easier to do (keyboard shortcuts, a toolbar with buttons) might encourage others to use them even more.

Why am I down on comment formatting, when even I use it and I was once all in favor of it? Legibility. For some reason, once formatting enters the comment world, I find those comments harder to read onscreen. It might be their reduced font size, or there might be something more to it, but I really find the formatting distracting to the comment.

Of course, I expect very few (if any) in the community to agree with me on this one. :)

share|improve this answer
4  
But it makes comments PRETTY!!! ...okay, I just really only use the code feature... –  Eric Aug 16 '09 at 5:04
2  
like everything else, it's ok when used sparingly, so I agree with your "let's not make it too easy to do this" –  Jeff Atwood Oct 2 '09 at 10:49

If this gets declined or you can't wait, you can use this Greasemonkey script to add Ctrl + B, Ctrl + I, and Ctrl + K shortcuts when editing comments.

share|improve this answer
    
I use it, however it does have some flaws in it: when you double click on a word to highlight it with a space after it, the script does this: *word_here *. Also, I like that it adds *|* (| = cursor) on the post editor because I have a habit of [CTRL] + [B] → [LEFT ARROW] → text here, so that annoys me sometimes, although I'm getting used to it. –  Annonomus Penguin Apr 4 at 1:23

I don't see anything wrong with this. If you are going to allow for the formatting, you might as well allow for the formatting shortcuts (if they are simple enough to implement).

I don't agree that the formatting is being abused or overused. I don't see how you can really have bold/italics/code get overused/abused unless the entire 600 character comment is made up of it.

share|improve this answer

Especially the Ctrl+K would be VERY useful. You know, not everyone has an USA Keyboard where the ` is conveniently placed! Many use a laptop without USA Keyboard and without a "true" numerical keypad, and so they have to fight to do Alt+Fn+M9O (096). I do think this is a localization problem (you program for your keyboard without thinking other persons could have different keyboards). It's like thinking everyone uses the . as a decimal separator.

share|improve this answer
    
At least do the code formatting: that is rarely abused... except when there is a new user that doesn't know` how to use the site. (But those users shouldn't be using the site in the first place) :D –  Annonomus Penguin Apr 4 at 1:25

German keyboards require an insane keystroke sequence to generate a tick character: Shift-`, Space. Yes, it is true: We need to press the Space key after having released the other two keys.

And adding code formatting to a comment requires doing that twice for every code snippet. I sometimes use the clipboard just for that one character.

share|improve this answer

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .