What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 128 Stack Exchange communities.

I don't think it would be a bad idea to allow tag "locking". The trouble is, we have some deprecated tags which we don't want to accept new questions for, but we can't just burninate mindlessly. The primary example of this is the tag. It's supposed to be obsolete, but new questions flood in every day because people don't take the time to read the tag description.

Locking a tag (or alternatively, deprecating it) would allow the removal of such tags from questions but not addition. As a fallback, questions can still be rolled back to a state where they possessed the tag in case a poor edit is made, but it cannot be added manually.

Without such a feature, I fear that the homework tag is here to stay.

share|improve this question
7  
I agree, it's like holding back the tide with a bottomless bucket. –  Tim Post Oct 19 '12 at 4:04
2  
I think the name "deprecated" is the much clearer suggestion for the feature compared to "locked". Locked makes it sound a bit like you can't edit the tag - its wiki/excerpt etc or something like that. –  hippietrail Oct 21 '12 at 10:04

2 Answers 2

up vote 25 down vote accepted

I like this idea. It gives users a clear indication as to why a tag can't be used, even though they see the tag applied to many other questions. It could also offer some tag specific advice on how to ask a question where a deprecated tag would be applied.

All in all, it would cut down on negative experiences, while giving the 'janitors' a fighting chance.

The reason we don't blacklist a tag until it's all but gone is the UI basically says "You can't add that tag", which confuses the heck out of people when they see it applied in lots of places. Similar frustration exists where the system demands that you tag a question, then tells you that you don't have the rep to create new tags.

Presumably if a tag that was widely used is now deprecated, there's a meta discussion about it. The deprecated / locked notice should point to that, while providing a short tl;dr; summary of why we're not allowing it any longer.

It seems to be the most considerate option, overall.

Edit

There is a caveat which could be a source of frustration. If someone edits a question where the tag is applied without removing the tag, the system will demand that the tag be removed. Whether we want to allow saves when a tag is merely locked instead of blacklisted (thus defining an even clearer distinction between the two states) warrants additional discussion if this is going to be implemented.

share|improve this answer
1  
Why not just change the error message when adding a blacklisted tag? Blacklisting and locking seem like basically the same feature –  Michael Mrozek Oct 19 '12 at 4:34
    
@MichaelMrozek Well, almost - provided that we could set the message. Blacklisting a tag that only has 100 uses isn't very problematic, because it will probably be cleaned up within a few hours of blacklisting. But yes, it seems that we can accomplish this by just clicking 'add deprecation notice?' when blacklisting and fill in a textbox. –  Tim Post Oct 19 '12 at 4:36
2  
I think it should be possible to make an edit that doesn't change (or remove) the tag without the system complaining. That seems like a good and useful difference between blacklisting and the proposed "locked" status. –  Mr.Wizard Oct 19 '12 at 5:48
1  
@Mr.Wizard Agreed. The system should only disallow adding locked tags. Leaving them alone/rolling them back on should be permitted. –  Alexis King Oct 19 '12 at 6:15
    
@JakeKing For those that don't follow meta and are just trying to clean up a question, I'd agree .. especially if the locked tag is one of the few a question has. If we can simply stop it from coming in, it will be gone eventually as people work on the cleanup. I don't see homework going away without this, or a Shog to the ninth power intervention. –  Tim Post Oct 19 '12 at 14:54

How about something like changing the display of tag from

to homework

Now old question that have such tags displayed in such way will probably raise the question why? Or even when adding such tags to new question they will certainly be curious, why does it have a strikethrough, then

  • User can be provided the information on the hover after the tag has been added.

  • Or after inclusion of the tag like homework in the question, we can then popup of a box below the tags and show why it is deprecated.

And whenever such deprecated tags have been added, you can then restrict the submission of the form, thus ensuring that the information is delivered and system is clean of new questions of deprecated tags.

share|improve this answer
1  
You can't hover tags in the tag entry field. You can only see their tag cards as you're entering them and auto-suggestions appear. –  BoltClock's a Unicorn Oct 19 '12 at 5:14
1  
@BoltClock'saUnicorn, How about my update? and I am talking about hovering after the tag has been added, not while adding tags. –  Starx Oct 19 '12 at 6:17
    
We don't want the tag to be added in the first place. It doesn't seem very effective to display it only after the tag has been added. –  BoltClock's a Unicorn Oct 19 '12 at 6:20
    
@BoltClock'saUnicorn, Restricting the submission of the post, if a deprecated tag has been added, should not that hard to implement as well. –  Starx Oct 19 '12 at 6:27
    
This is certainly raise the question why? ... You're very optimistic there...stick around on Meta for some time and you'll know why (one word: question-ban). –  Time Traveling Bobby Oct 19 '12 at 8:24
2  
To be clear, if a tag is locked it should be shown this way on questions that have it, while still rejecting the tag on new questions? –  Tim Post Oct 19 '12 at 14:57
    
@SulfurizedDemonbobby, I am already under question ban. –  Starx Oct 19 '12 at 16:52
    
@TimPost, Exactly :) Thus the old questions can be sorted by best suitable methods and there will no new question to worry about. So in time such tag problem will be solved gradually. –  Starx Oct 19 '12 at 16:53
1  
@Starx: Interesting...anyway, I did not mean you, I meant the inability of many other users to understand the simple error message and read that big FAQ entry. ... Despite countless attempts to make it fool-proof. –  Time Traveling Bobby Oct 20 '12 at 6:41

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .