In the new review queue, I look at proposed reopens. What I want to know, more often than not, is what, if anything, has the OP or someone else done to improve the question. I can answer this question now, but I bet that the UI could make it easier to answer this question.
To add an analogy: on a court of appeals, the judges do not retry the case. They review the lower court's decision. It is all about reviewing the process, and not about reconsidering the original facts. To me, the review/reopen is a court of appeals for close votes, unless have been edits.