What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 133 Stack Exchange communities.

TL;DR: I've gotten a previous account/ip blocked from asking questions, pretty much the only thing I plan on using Stack Overflow for until I'm more experienced. I don't want to be a d*ck and consistently break any rules I might be breaking, but don't understand what I'm doing wrong.


I recently had my account blocked from using the sites most basic features, essentially removing it's usefulness to me on that account. I don't want to continue breaking any rules that have gotten me banned because I don't want to offend a community of (mostly) people who are here to help others.

So I'd like it if someone could point out why almost all the questions I've created have received a negative voting score. I'd also like to know if people are banned solely because of downvotes, and if not what have I done to deserve a ban.

EDIT: the posts aren't only on this account, they are also on user1882226 and fazerXYZ

EDIT2: to clarify, I have already read the faq and how-to-ask.html. I did this before asking any questions on my first account, and I am already complying with these.

share|improve this question
    
Check the comments on your other question meta.stackexchange.com/questions/160454/… –  iDev Dec 27 '12 at 7:45
    
5  
Spend some time reading the faq instead of wasting time on changing IPs and creating accounts –  Bhuvan Rikka 웃 Dec 27 '12 at 7:48
5  
P.s. if this is indeed also an account of yours you've not started using this site 3 days ago. And you've received several comments on your downvoted posts there as well. And instead of working around bans, I'm sure you've read this by now as well of course? –  Bart Dec 27 '12 at 7:49
7  
Fortunately ip and account bans will not prevent me from using a website for more then about 3 minutes, as I can change my ip and create a new account. The Moderators will love to hear that. Creating multiple accounts to circumvent a question ban will result in a permanent ban...the hard way. –  Time Traveling Bobby Dec 27 '12 at 7:55
    
@Bart, I have read most of it excluding some of the links, I disagree with certain things such as help vampirism which I would like to go into detail but it's far too philosophical and complicated as to why I disagree with it, but I will say this: I once couldn't use CreateWindowEx. After finding sample code and playing with it I now will probably never have problems with that or any other included functions. Some people learn more slowly then others, calling those that learn slowly "vampires" and shunning them is something I think is offensive. –  user1931290 Dec 27 '12 at 8:12
    
oh and you're right, apparently it just seemed like about 3 days ago. –  user1931290 Dec 27 '12 at 8:14
2  
@user1931290 that particular question would have been answered by any textbook you could have picked up on the language. Even by any textbook on any somewhat similar language. And yes, we do expect you to do your homework. To teach yourself. We are not here for that. Or at least not at a level that basic. –  Bart Dec 27 '12 at 8:17
    
By reading the comments i feel this site is like a School with some strict teachers and the users who asked questions should be have a fear to ask their questions like a School boy. –  user833985 Dec 27 '12 at 9:24
1  
@user833985 That's not the case. We just ask that you put some effort into your own research before asking a question. Like reading a book on the programming language you're trying to learn for example. If you do that, and your question is clear, you will have no problem participating as a beginner. Just make sure you read the FAQ and you should be good to go. But given that this particular user kept asking bad questions, created multiple accounts and stated here and in another question that he would keep doing so, his reception was less than warm. Any regular user should be fine. –  Bart Dec 27 '12 at 9:29
    
@Bart Please see the below link. link I Feel this question as silly which is not related to programming. Changing an option from the menu is not deserve any single down votes but one up votes. also it passes all rules like constructive,not localize and etc etc. –  user833985 Dec 27 '12 at 9:44
    
Also I can see something similiar to this thread already been asked.linkhow come these are related to programming. These questions should be asked to the technical people who installed the VS to the respective system or just google it. –  user833985 Dec 27 '12 at 9:44
    
@user833985 What's the problem with the first question you link? It's about software commonly used by programmers. It's not the most brilliant of questions, but it's fine. It's on-topic for the site as specified in the FAQ. That said, if you need clarifications of your own, by all means ask a question about it on Meta. –  Bart Dec 27 '12 at 9:49
    
@user833985 If you think they are duplicates, flag one as such for moderator attention. We can't be expected to see everything. So if you do, great. –  Bart Dec 27 '12 at 10:04

1 Answer 1

You get downvoted because the questions you ask are not good in one way or another. It's really as simple as that. You have already received several comments on your questions, so you can't be completely oblivious to the fact that something is wrong. But let's go through some of them on your various accounts.

  • There was this (now deleted) question of yours: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/14049927/

    In this question you were essentially asking us to provide you with a tutorial. That's not what we do here. Ask a question about a practical problem you face and we'll answer it. Question and answer. We don't link to tutorials. We don't recommend books. And we don't write entire tutorials. Don't ask us to tell you where you can find a solution. Ask us for help with the practical problem.

  • Then there is I created a messed up program that makes a beep for some reason? can someone explain this to me?

    Essentially you're mucking around with code. Adding stuff that does really not belong there. A fun playground if you will. But with that, the awesomeness of the post does not go beyond the title. Something ended up beeping in the mess you created. While perhaps a fun exercise for someone to figure out, this is only ever relevant to you and the mess you created. As such it's too localized and closing it for that reason is fair.

  • On another account we have http://stackoverflow.com/revisions/14015451/1

    Without even looking at the content, look at the post. How does that look to you? Does it seem clear? Now try to read the text. It took me several times to even grasp what you were getting at, trying not to get lost in the mean time.

    For one very basic thing, format the code as code. Make it stand out. Split the text up in several easy to grasp paragraphs. Then we might still get lost in the question, but at least you've provided some clarity. And the comments on the particular question and the answer you received clearly indicate this. The users didn't get what you were asking.

That's 3 questions for you. Downvotes and close votes explained. Now read all of the content I've linked to before to see how you can improve. There are:

Read all of them in full and make sure you understand. Not just that, make sure you understand where all your downvoted posts fail in some regard. Once you have a clear picture of that, improve your content where possible and see if you can get yourself unbanned.

But the major things are: Focus your questions. Keep them on-topic as specified by the FAQ. And please please please be clear.

As for the whole "I'll keep creating new accounts" deal.....yeah, don't do that. You'll run out of steam far before the moderators do. Just read this instead.

share|improve this answer
1  
Basically, SO is not really intended for people who have no clue what they're doing. stackoverflow.com/questions/13743150/… is the best example of that, it shows practically no understanding of how to program in C++ (or most other programming languages, since this is a common mechanism). –  Barmar Dec 27 '12 at 8:11
3  
@Barmar Indeed. Users should by no means be afraid of asking a question, even if they are beginners. But don't expect the site to teach you how to program. You've got to learn this and we'll help you with your problems on the way. But a question like that would have been answered by any beginner text-book out there. Even the bad ones. –  Bart Dec 27 '12 at 8:15
1  
Thanks barmer and bart, I think the basic reason is due to "noobishness". Anyways I guess I'll just have to keep creating accounts and changing IP's anytime I get blocked from asking questions so that I can ask noobish questions again. I do my homework on the questions first, when about 15 minutes of google and half an hour of playing with the code doesn't help me I come here. Also, being banned isn't going to stop me since I basically look at it as adding 3 additional minutes to asking my question, since my question still gets answered (and yes those answers do help me.) It's too bad. thanks. –  user1931290 Dec 27 '12 at 8:29
8  
WTF? NO. Don't keep creating new accounts. Haven't you read my answer at all? Stop that. And no, 15 minutes of Google is not enough. Man, I'm sorry, but I did my best even after your previous question. If you receive a more permanent ban, it's all your own doing. <--- To anyone reading this, insert random expletives please. –  Bart Dec 27 '12 at 8:32
    
I don't really understand why you think I can get a more permanent ban than ip/account ban, unless they plan on creating more steps to deter me from getting into this website like requiring rep just to ask questions or unless they make it so only whitelisted users who pass some sort of test can ask questions, I doubt they can do much more to prevent me from getting in here. Maybe I'm ignorant but so far I haven't encountered anything more "permanent" then IP/account bans... anywhere. –  user1931290 Dec 27 '12 at 9:05
3  
By all means feel free to try. I can't see you switching to any constructive behaviour soon, no matter how much effort I would put into helping you out. So yes, focus on creating new accounts and circumventing bans. –  Bart Dec 27 '12 at 9:07
    
k, before you go I want you to know you have my sincere thanks either way though. goodbye. –  user1931290 Dec 27 '12 at 9:14

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .