I got dinged for my disinclination to vote to reopen on http://stackoverflow.com/review/reopen/1470791.
Now, my policy is simple. If five people voted to close something, I don't second-guess them. If the question has not been edited, I don't vote to reopen it.
I object to being told off in this case.
I don't claim that no one should ever second-guess a close vote, but I don't see why I should have to.