I advertised the Hinduism Proposal on Area 51 using this referral link. This is what I see in my Area 51 reputation point history:
- I have received reputation for four referrals
- I have two referrals which I haven't received reputation for
- The page lists four referrals under my name
- The page lists five people who have joined after I have
None of this matches up. Reputation points aside, there are two referrals unaccounted for. If the fifth guy who joined was a referral of mine, then (a) it should show up as my referral, and (b) there still is one referral unaccounted for.