I got this as a review task:
I read the post, added a comment that I thought would help clarify, and voted to leave open. However, it should have been obvious to me that it clearly should have been closed.
What should have tipped me off?
I don't make it a habit of rushing through these tasks (I think I've missed one or two otherwise) and I know that this kind of thing is subjective, but the tests should be obviously one way or the other, and I don't feel this one was.