I failed this reopen review:
I clicked "reopen" and apparently I should have left the question closed.
I do not understand why: The question was closed because it was not phrased clearly, it underwent extensive editing by the OP. I believe that in its current, edited, version it is a clear question now and should be given a second chance.
Can you please tell me why I am wrong here?
Why should this question be left closed even after OP's edit?
Is it such a clear-cut case that it should become an audit item?