When looking at this question, it looked to me like it belonged on Super User, as it was not asking about programming. However, when I tried to flag it, it was a known good audit and I failed it, causing me to be banned from reviewing for 7 days. Am I right or wrong in disputing this audit?
It's pretty clear that the question you linked is off-topic. It got picked by the audit because several viewers upvoted it, and nobody bothered to cast a close vote. Unfortunately, not everyone pays attention to the site rules, and the folks who visited this question were clearly only interested in its content, not the site rules.