The simple fact that you have 2 separate questions saying the opposite I think covers why this is opinion-based. Different people are going to interpret it differently and have differing opinions on which is better. So in that respect, any answer is going to have some basis in opinion and based on personal preference.
There is a class of questions that have been loving dubbed Gorilla vs Shark. The blog article I linked provides the full story, but this question, falls into that category. You are basically asking "which is better" and assuming that one is clearly superior in all cases and won't require a novel to answer.
To help better improve your question, ideally you need to provide some scope for your problem. Things like how often is the database being written too, how much data, are you editing or inserting or deleting, etc. These bits of info would narrow the question down and allow someone to provide a good concise answer.
From the wording on your problem, however, it looks like you don't have an actual problem and were wondering in general, so it may be difficult you to restructure this in the way I mentioned, but I think that is the best way to do it.