What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 134 Stack Exchange communities.

Let me start with a story:

I was looking at a question somewhere or other on stackoverflow, and I saw one of the answers had 18 upvotes. It was a very good answer. A little habit of mine, I looked at the answerer's reputation. It was 189. Thinking it was weird, as most users with that quality answers have thousands of reputation points, I went to his/her profile page. That was his/her only question or answer. When I had 189 reputation, I had dozens of answers. Even now, with more than 1000 reputation, none of my answers have more than 5 upvotes. None of my questions have more than 2. I think there should be a badge for having a lot of questions instead of just being lucky enough to have an answer that gets a lot of upvotes. I don't have an idea of a name, but feel free to give suggestions in the comments

share|improve this question
So reward people who provide a lot of mediocre posts? I'd prefer to focus on quality, not quantity. Plenty of sites out there already have the quantity part nailed down. We don't want to become one of those. –  Aaron Bertrand Dec 8 '13 at 4:20
I think there should be a badge for having a lot of questions instead of just being lucky enough to have an answer that gets a lot of upvotes Call it "I'm Average!"? –  jonsca Dec 8 '13 at 4:21
I'm not sure why this is attracting quite so much negative energy. It's not that bad of an idea as soon as you add some checks to eliminate any incentives for post noise. You asked for suggestions - here's one: Add minimum quality checks: A bronze badge for having 5 answers with a minimum score of 1, a silver for having 25 with a minimum score of 2, and a gold for having a 100 with a minimum score of 5. (I didn't test ANY of those numbers - it's just an example.) –  Jaydles Dec 17 '13 at 15:39

3 Answers 3

This would mean someone could get a badge just for asking dozens of crap questions and doing no research at all, which isn't behaviour that should be encouraged.

Au contraire, generally people should try to do their own research and come to a Stack Exchange site when they can't find the answer. Then, when they do, hopefully they'll be asking a pretty good question that's stimulating and can receive great answers.

When they do that, surprisingly enough they'll get badges and reputation for it, and so will the people providing great answers! Those are the badges we need - and have. Ones for lots-o-questions and lots-o-answers aren't.

share|improve this answer
then there could be something like the answers/questions need to have a certain amount of votes to be counted? –  Markasoftware Dec 8 '13 at 4:57
If we set it at 10, you'd be getting Nice Answer badges anyway, and it'd be a badge for having lots of badges. If it's set at, say, 5, we're still just rewarding asking a lot of mediocre questions. –  doppelgreener Dec 8 '13 at 5:04
Mind you, we do have badges for having accumulated a high score in a tag. –  doppelgreener Dec 8 '13 at 5:06
then why don't we just have accepted answers instead of a vote count? –  Markasoftware Dec 8 '13 at 18:08
@Markasoftware That's a possible good badge! We do have Tenacious and Unsung hero for users with many zero-scoring accepted answers, but that isn't slightly-scored accepted answers. –  doppelgreener Dec 8 '13 at 21:25

That's a terrible idea. Badges are for rewarding good behavior. Your proposed badge does not do that. It is better to have a few excellent posts than a ton of mediocre ones.

share|improve this answer
It would encourage people to be more active in the site. –  Markasoftware Dec 8 '13 at 4:57
There is already plenty of encouragement to that nature, isn't there? –  doppelgreener Dec 8 '13 at 5:05
@Markasoftware More activity is great but never at the cost of quality –  James Dec 8 '13 at 15:01

Excellent suggestion. Actually this has already been thought of and implemented.

First you have the Unsung hero and Tenacious badges

enter image description here enter image description here

Next you've got the by-category tag badges,

enter image description here

All of these reward "spread-out" reputation, precisely in the manner you've described.

share|improve this answer
Hi downvoter! Feel free to explain the reason for your downvote. –  bobobobo Dec 17 '13 at 0:53
These aren't already-implemented versions of what's being requested, which is a badge for having a lot of low-rep questions. We don't have a badge for lots of low-rep answers, either: Unsung Hero is for when you've provided a lot of helpful (accepted!) answers that haven't received community acknowledgement. The tag badges are for displaying expertise in a single tag. Both of those have constraints beyond "lots of answers". –  doppelgreener Dec 17 '13 at 1:52
Actually, I need to correct myself: the request isn't even for "lots of low-rep questions", it's just for "lots of questions" - regardless of any other factor. We definitely don't have a badger that is simply "lots of questions" or "lots of answers", regardless of scores or anything else. –  doppelgreener Dec 17 '13 at 2:28
Well, he said "I had dozens of answers. Even now, with more than 1000 reputation, none of my answers have more than 5 upvotes" .. later he says "I think there should be a badge for having a lot of questions" ... but then "instead of just being lucky enough to have an answer that gets a lot of upvotes". Rather than take the question literally, I'm saying there are badges for your dozens of answers that don't get that many upvotes. –  bobobobo Dec 17 '13 at 3:47
Ok, but we don't have a badge that specifically rewards lots of questions/answers, low-scoring or not. We have ones that might incidentally reward that behaviour, if that behaviour happens to fit within other good constraints (the answers are accepted, or are a continuous demonstration of expertise or experience on a particular topic). –  doppelgreener Dec 17 '13 at 3:54

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .