What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 131 Stack Exchange communities.

I was working through some of the Low Quality Posts review queue when I came across this answer.

The answer is simply a snippet of code that, in fact, does try to solve the issue of the question. However, it is of low quality. Now, I could recommend deletion for it being low-quality, but it really should just be expanded on by the poster, if possible. Therefore, instead of choosing to recommend deletion, I decided to leave a comment on it asking the poster to expand on it to improve the quality of their answer.

(Perhaps this is where a debate will come in. Maybe I should just recommend deletion?)

To me, the act of leaving a comment is an action that I have taken on the post while in the review queue. However, now to move on to the next post, I still have to click one of the action buttons.

  • Looks Good - Well, no, the answer doesn't look good. It should be expanded on it.
  • Edit - It's formatted well but any other changes would be radical.
  • Recommend Deletion - I don't feel it should be deleted, just improved.
  • Skip - Skip this review task on move on. Seems like the only logical choice.

However, if I click Skip, it is not counted as if I reviewed the item, even though I did by leaving a comment. I think this should be addressed.

Proposal

While in the Low Quality Posts review queue, if you leave a comment on a post and then chose Skip, it should increment your progress instead of ignoring it as it does now. Additionally, perhaps when you successfully leave a comment on the post, the Skip button changes to say Next to indicate you have taken action on the post.

share|improve this question
    
Skip is never an action. If you don't think a post needs to be deleted right away (which I am assuming you didn't), then "looks good" is the right response –  psubsee2003 Mar 6 at 19:02
4  
Personally I think the "Looks Good" button is named wrong. It is confusing –  psubsee2003 Mar 6 at 19:10
    
@psubsee2003 I agree. Perhaps just changing the text on that button would be a good fix. –  Michael Irigoyen Mar 6 at 19:14
1  
Seems like low-quality review should be like the late answers queue -- allowing votes (particularly down) and multiple actions before clicking "I'm done". –  Josh Caswell Mar 6 at 19:27
    
@JoshCaswell it's more just a mis-understanding of the meaning of the buttons though. If downvoting, or adding a comment, is enough that you feel the post is no longer "so bad that it warrants deletion", then "looks good" is the right button. "Looks good" doesn't actually mean, "this is a good post", it means, "this isn't so completely awful that we need to delete it". We just need a way of conveying that in something that fits on a button. –  Servy Mar 6 at 20:15
    
@Servy: Maybe "Good enough"? –  Ilmari Karonen Mar 8 at 1:21

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .