Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 158 Stack Exchange communities.

What is meta?
Here's how it works:
  1. Any Stack Exchange user can ask a question
  2. The community provides support, votes on ideas, and reports bugs
  3. Your voice helps shape the way Stack Exchange operates

Possible Duplicate:
Is the Critic badge badge awarded prematurely

I currently have the Critic badge, but no downvotes. I was immediately awarded the badge upon clicking the down arrow, even though I canceled before the downvote was made permanent.

Expected behavior: The badge should be awarded when the downvote becomes un-undoable, not before.

The related question is tagged "by design" but this behavior has resulted in an inconsistent state — namely, I have a badge without the prereqs.

share|improve this question

marked as duplicate by Ladybug Killer, random, BinaryMisfit Oct 27 '09 at 14:41

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

You're right, but it's already beaten to death in your dupe link. Badges are almost never revoked. Jeff doesn't care about these tiny inconsistencies. He's not a real programmer, you know... – Ladybug Killer Oct 27 '09 at 14:02
That has happened to me – Benny Jan 22 '11 at 5:08

By design, awarded badges are not removed due to further user actions except for the following exception:

  1. Tag badges are removed if the tag score falls below the required threshold.
  2. After accounts merge the criteria for most badges is re-calculated (e.g. for Nice Question) and if the merged account doesn't meet the requirements the badge is not passed.
share|improve this answer
Not true. Beta badge was removed. – Ladybug Killer Oct 27 '09 at 14:10
@John Smithers I still have my Beta badge, when were they removed? – dlamblin Oct 27 '09 at 14:14
@dlamblin: Not all were removed, but some.… – Ladybug Killer Oct 27 '09 at 14:24
@John but that was just an exception to the rule, due to a change in the badge requisites. It would be equivalent to creating a new badge with a different name and eliminating the old one. The situation the OP described is different: it's only his actions and status that changed, not any design. He was a critic once, and, on SO, once a critic, always a critic. – Daniel Daranas Oct 27 '09 at 14:54
@Daniel: I know this pretty well (as you can see by my comment to the question). So what do you want to tell me? – Ladybug Killer Oct 27 '09 at 15:09
@John: That "By design, awarded badges are never removed" is still true, or true-ish. A "truer" statement would be "By design, awarded badges are never removed due to further user actions." Removing badges due to the fact that a badge was substantially redefined falls into a different category of actions. – Daniel Daranas Oct 27 '09 at 15:24
@Daniel: I do not want to know how you define false ;) – Ladybug Killer Oct 27 '09 at 20:24
#define false 0 :-) – Daniel Daranas Oct 28 '09 at 9:04
Nice I did that? – Benny Jan 22 '11 at 5:07

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .