Is the Critic badge badge awarded prematurely
I currently have the Critic badge, but no downvotes. I was immediately awarded the badge upon clicking the down arrow, even though I canceled before the downvote was made permanent.
Expected behavior: The badge should be awarded when the downvote becomes un-undoable, not before.
The related question is tagged "by design" but this behavior has resulted in an inconsistent state — namely, I have a badge without the prereqs.