What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 133 Stack Exchange communities.

Summary:

Let me see the original question while answering.

Long version:

This is my pattern:

  • Click on "answer"
  • Open the original question in a new tab by clicking on "Return to original question" ( now gone )
  • Switch back and forward to see if I'm missing something.

It is important to me to look several times at the question. I don't want to write a good answer and get downvoted only because the OP said:

Foo

and I typed:

Bar

and have comments and downvotes saying "He said Foo not Bar" and deviate the attention from the answer to the small mistakes I may have committed ( enough is to take care of the spelling already )

I would like to have ( honestly, I don't really have a clue of "how" ) a view of the original question while answering.

It was already a hassle having to switch between tabs, but now the link is gone, a just a couple of click harder now I have to:

  • click back
  • dismiss whatever I might have written
  • open the "answer" in a new tab
  • and made a lot of mistakes because the question is now at my left and not at my right where it was.

phew!

Having this view, will allow me ( us ) to give better answers, and to use the system in a more "humane" way.

Related: what-happened-to-the-return-to-answer-link

share|improve this question
    
Though I also would like that link back, I wonder where you need to Click on "answer" ? I miss that link while editing existing answers or question, but to answer, I just start typing on the bottom of the page? (See workarounds at the related question you mentioned.) –  Arjan Dec 9 '09 at 18:48
    
see: meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1189/… –  fretje Dec 26 '09 at 18:05

1 Answer 1

up vote 4 down vote accepted

Yes, please do that. If, as stated in the related question, the idea is to prevent quoting, then have the original question appear in a non copyable portion of the page.

I tend to think that if quoting is as much a temptation as Joel says, we would see that much amount of quoting already, regardless of how the site works now. And I don't see questions quoted, at all!

share|improve this answer
4  
The quoting thing doesn't make any sense. I fail to see what might be bad about quoting and I certainly don't see much quoting on any of the trilogy sites. –  innaM Oct 31 '09 at 9:42

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .