What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 130 Stack Exchange communities.

The conversation often continues in the Comments and important information is held in the comments. I'd like to have threaded comments there. It would make it easier for people who are editing answers to be able to see the real useful information in the comments separately from the conversations that occurs in the comment stream below each answer.

share|improve this question
6  
If they were so packed with goodness, they should be rolled out into answers. Otherwise, they're noise. –  random Nov 26 '09 at 11:33
2  
The problem with threaded comments is that the left margin will overflow in flame wars :) –  LeakyCode Nov 26 '09 at 11:43
1  
Re: Mehrdad: I think flame wars happen in any comment stream, and the community policing needs to manage that whether there are threaded or single stream comments. Re: random: I agree that comments sometimes contain great information that need to be refactored into the answer. My request for threaded comments is to make that process easier. –  Stewart Robinson Nov 26 '09 at 12:03
4  
@Steward: SO has already managed it by positioning itself as a Q&A site rather than a discussion site by discouraging random discussion in FAQ. –  LeakyCode Nov 26 '09 at 15:57
1  
See my Greasemonkey script here: meta.stackexchange.com/questions/43055/… –  balpha Mar 21 '10 at 14:24
    
You certainly need discussion sin meta.stackoverflow because isn't this site all about discussion problems and enhancements to SO? –  user131750 Apr 18 '10 at 17:40
    
Hmm, I want to bring this into discussion again. I still think threaded comments would be helpful. –  bobobobo Aug 25 '12 at 15:35
    
@bobobobo we already have ways to get threaded comments. There is chat, and a threaded comments script on Stackapps. –  Robert Harvey Aug 25 '12 at 18:05
    
@RobertHarvey I mean as a default.. REDDIT STYLE!! (Yes, I said the unspeakable). –  bobobobo Aug 25 '12 at 18:13

5 Answers 5

Jeff really hates threaded comments. Personally I like them - when represented in a useful way, with easy ways to mute/highlight appropriate subthreads, but I doubt that we'll ever see them on SO.

Having said that I like them, I'm not even sure they'd be appropriate for SO anyway, which is more designed for Q&A than discussion. Sometimes I wish there were some way of leaving the questions/answers as they are, but launching a new discussion (with threading) where suitable. Can't see it happening in the near future though.

share|improve this answer
5  
Just open Wave! –  Ladybug Killer Nov 26 '09 at 11:58
2  
I didn't know of Jeff's hatrid of threaded comments. have you noticed that when people merge information from comments into the answer the comments then read very strangely unless you have been following the conversation over time. There should be a way to mark a comment as integrated back into the answer. Oops new feature request. I'm off to lunch –  Stewart Robinson Nov 26 '09 at 12:05
    
Stew: "Can we have threaded comments?" Jeff: I hate, I hate!! –  bobobobo Dec 18 '10 at 18:31
    
@LadybugKiller support.google.com/wave/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=1083134 –  bobobobo Aug 25 '12 at 15:34
    
@bobobobo: You are late to the party, aren't you? ;) –  Ladybug Killer Aug 27 '12 at 9:54

As Jon seems to address, threaded comments are great for following discussion. Jeff has said before that he explicitly wants to avoid discussion on SO, so if threaded comments help discussion, it would seem that adding threaded comments would, in a sense, be giving a blessing of sorts to discussions on SO. It's nice in theory, but it goes against the current mission of the site.

I do like the idea of a discussion area, though. Often times, I have a question or discussion topic that I would very much like to bring in front of this particular community, but it's not necessarily programming related. Sometimes you want to ask your "work peers" questions not necessarily related to your "work."

share|improve this answer

Threaded comments and threaded answers would be great - for another site.

On this site, it would just encourage discussion, which is discouraged.

share|improve this answer

I truly wonder why discussion is so discouraged herein. Some answers can be very difficult to get at and discussion about the answer could help a really good answer to emerge instead of having an endless list of partial answers or a hard to follow comment stream that needs to be completely followed through to get at the real juice.

On the other hand, I realize that many questions in the Stack Exchange sites are simple enough and warrant that a single right answer can do it.

A certain form of argumentative questions can be supported through the wiki mode. Perhaps having threaded comments only in the community wiki mode would be of great help in getting these hard questions to emerge. Since there are no reputation points involved in community wiki mode, editing them also solves the difficult task of assigning proper reputation points though there are some solutions to this.

It is true that arguments can be difficult to manage and often degenerate. That said, the community participating in the Stack Exchange sites is thus far very disciplined in this regards and seldom stray off topic. Yes, sure you can find plenty of examples where things just went wrong, but overall it is the exception.

Stack Exchange sites have gone a long way since their inception and are quickly becoming THE reference in many subjects. But it still lacks a certain depth, discouraging discussion certainly helped with the discipline, but it also gave the community a glass ceiling, shackles of sorts, that prevents more difficult answers to emerge on some questions.

In short, encouraging argumentation and discussion at large would most likely not be a good idea. But allowing some question to generate discussion and providing a specific UI enhancements to support discussion would benefit the whole community. Perhaps Community Wiki is the way, but perhaps a new mode of providing answers would be required to support argumentation in a constructive way.

share|improve this answer

Threaded comments would be useful.

Compare these 2 views of the same discussion

unthreaded

(Visual jumping highlighted in red)

unthreaded

threaded

threaded

share|improve this answer

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .