What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 150 Stack Exchange communities.

Here's an idea for a new set of badges:

  • Conversation Starter (Bronze): received comments from five different people (in total across all answers)
  • Catalyst (Silver) : received comments from five different people on a single answer

both can be awarded only once.

Update: for both only count comments on answers, not on questions, because for questions there are usually lot of "did you mean?" comments.

Another Update: it seems that people are worried that most comments would be just pointing out how wrong the answer is. That is a sad (but maybe appropriate) view. I think it can be amended by only counting comments on answers with no downvotes.

share|improve this question
@Another update, that is your second "patch" for your suggestion... whatever happened to KISS? – juanformoso Dec 18 '09 at 13:09
Even if this were a good idea (I'm against it, BTW) you set the bar way too low. – dmckee Dec 18 '09 at 21:01
Can precious metals act as a catalyst? – Andrew Grimm Sep 17 '10 at 9:55

2 Answers 2

In order to receive comments, there must be something wrong or not clear in your post... why would this be encouraged?

share|improve this answer
Good point. Many comments are like that. But even though, if a wrong answer results in a long discussion, that often makes for an interesting read. – Thilo Dec 18 '09 at 12:40
Also, there is a badge for leaving ten comments. Those may not be too valuable either... – Thilo Dec 18 '09 at 12:41
But that badge is essentially for giving feedback on other people's questions - a useful community activity. – MartW Dec 18 '09 at 12:44
I suppose to eliminate comments that just point out a wrong answer, one could count only answers with no downvotes. – Thilo Dec 18 '09 at 13:00
@Thilo - but some comments on downvoted answers are explanations as to why they were downvoted. Those types of comments should be encouraged. – Graeme Perrow Dec 18 '09 at 16:43
@Graeme: those comments are encouraged by the existing "Commentator/Pundit" badges. These new badges are for receiving comments. – Thilo Dec 19 '09 at 0:43

I'd like to bump this feature request, with minor modifications. I suggest the following:

  1. A bronze badge for receiving 10 or more comments on a single question or answer.
  2. A silver badge for receiving 25 or more comments on a single question or answer.
  3. A gold badge for receiving 100 or more comments on a single question or answer.

In all cases, your own comments are not counted.

Call them what you will, but I think this would be a good feature.

To counter @Downvoter's post that comments should be discouraged: why have comments at all? They're not just for clarification, they're for communication that is outside the realm of, but still relevant to, the question/answer at hand. Perhaps this might encourage more "discussion" in comments, but I don't think that'd be a bad thing.

share|improve this answer

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .