What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 127 Stack Exchange communities.

If I downvote a question or answer, and the post is edited, it looks like I can make one another downvote. However, when I click the downvote button again, the result appears to be exactly the inverse: instead of downvote I upvote.

I believe that this is the same situation for up-votes (producing down the second time instead of up).

Is this a bug?

EDIT

Problem

Actually, BOTH tooltips(up and down) informs about UNDO the action - even if you didn't any up/down vote - "...(click again to undo)". This is a little embarrassing.

Let's say I voted on a topic. Then after some time I visit the same topic and I don't know anymore if I voted it or not(sometimes the voted topic is highlighted(up or down), sometimes not - it's not a rule). So I decide to vote this topic down, but in fact I undo(?) it, or even reverse(?) it. Neverknow.

Possible solution

After first up/down usage the up/down buttons tooltips should change.

By e.g. in the downvote situation: the downvote button should have a "undo" tooltip text, the upvote button - a "reverse" tooltip text.

share|improve this question
    
@serhio - both buttons need both tooltips. You can reverse an down-vote in the same way as reversing an up-vote. Actually I've just thought - perhaps the tooltip should change depending on the status of the arrows. If neither has been clicked then tooltips as now. If a vote has been cast then the one on the vote should remain, but the other one could have the "click to reverse" tooltip. –  ChrisF Jan 5 '10 at 22:26
    
@ChrisF. Ya. I edited the proposal considering your observation. –  serhio Jan 5 '10 at 22:30
    
thanks everybody to experiment on my own question :) –  serhio Jan 5 '10 at 23:05
add comment

1 Answer

No, you can not down-vote (or up-vote) twice, even if the question/answer has been edited.

If you have voted on a question/answer, and then that question/answer is edited, you can undo your vote by clicking again on the same vote-arrow, or you can reverse your vote by clicking on the other arrow.

So iow, when you click a particular vote-arrow for the second time, it gets undone, not reversed. (I think that's the behavior that you are observing?)


The SOFU way of undo-downvoting:

  1. Downvote a post (score of post: -1)
  2. Wait till it was edited
  3. Click the downvote button again (score of post: 0)

(The scores assume that you are the only voter.)

The SOFU art of reversing your vote:

  1. Downvote a post (score of post: -1)
  2. Wait till it was edited
  3. Click the upvote button (score of post: 1)

(The scores assume that you are the only voter.)

share|improve this answer
    
when you click a particular vote-arrow for the second time, it gets undone, not reversed this is not obvious at all... So, after a upvote should be visible only the down image, viceversa for a downvote... –  serhio Jan 5 '10 at 15:27
1  
@serhio: Why? Then you would only be able to reverse a vote, not to undo it. You're limiting features with that, not adding. –  fretje Jan 5 '10 at 16:09
    
@fretje: So, what is the difference between reverse and undo a vote? If I downvote a post to -3 with my vote, undo ==> -2, and reverse ==> -2... same thing. –  serhio Jan 5 '10 at 16:41
    
No, reverse ==> -1 because you took away a downvote and added an upvote. Also, check the tooltip on the arrow; it tells you "Click again to undo". –  mmyers Jan 5 '10 at 16:48
    
Finally, I can do ony one action the second time. As I understood, this is the UNDO action (neutralizes your vote). -3 ==> -2. So the presence of a single arrow is more transparent(clear, evident) to the users that a tooltip... IMO.. –  serhio Jan 5 '10 at 17:07
    
@serhio: you can do only one action indeed, but one of 2 different actions: undo [-3 ==> -2] or reverse (change from down-vote to up-vote) [-3 ==> -1]. So you need 2 different buttons. –  fretje Jan 5 '10 at 17:33
    
@fretje: So, clarify me: When I click up I undo, when down I reverse? –  serhio Jan 5 '10 at 17:43
1  
@serhio: Yes indeed, or more generic (for both up- and down-votes): if you click the button that's already highlighted you undo the vote. The other (not-highlighted) button reverses the vote. I actually find it quite intuitive that way. –  fretje Jan 5 '10 at 17:45
    
@fretje: Actually, BOTH tooltips(up and dow) informs about UNDO the action. "Click to UNDO". The downvote button should have a "undo" tooltip text, the upvote button - a "reverse" tooltip text. –  serhio Jan 5 '10 at 22:18
1  
@serhio - both buttons need both tooltips. You can reverse an down-vote in the same way as reversing an up-vote. Actually I've just thought - perhaps the tooltip should change depending on the status of the arrows. If neither has been clicked then tooltips as now. If a vote has been cast then the one on the vote should remain, but the other one could have the "click to reverse" tooltip –  ChrisF Jan 5 '10 at 22:26
    
@ChrisF: Finally, to be more clear, do you agree or not the current behavior? –  serhio Jan 5 '10 at 23:07
2  
Tooltips are fine, but let's be honest, if it doesn't fit the User Model (what the user expects it to do), then it's wrong. And the only way to find out if it's wrong is to find people who have never used the system and ask them. –  Mark Henderson Jan 6 '10 at 0:26
    
The reverse in "click to reverse" is too easily misunderstood (what are you reversing? could mean "undo the previous downvote" when clicking upvote---I think this is directly related to serhio's misunderstanding). "Click to undo downvote and instead upvote" on the up button (even though it's stored differently, the user is conceptually doing two things) and "Click to undo downvote" on the down button. –  Gnome Jan 6 '10 at 1:13
add comment

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .