What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 131 Stack Exchange communities.

Currently when the "Hide Ignored Tags" option is enabled in the preferences, any question with an ignored AND an interesting tag is hidden. This keeps many "interesting" questions from being seen when this option is used. This works fine for those who want to ignore homework, but not so good if the volume of questions in topics alien to the user is overwhelming.

To fix this, it is proposed that a new option "Keep Interesting Tags" be added. When "Hide Ignored Tags" is enabled, the behavior of enabling "Keep Interesting Tags" is to show any questions that have both interesting and ignored tags. When "Hide Ignored Tags" is disabled, the setting of "Keep Interesting Tags" has no effect (and could be hidden from the user).

share|improve this question

6 Answers 6

I agree with question.

share|improve this answer

I also agree with this request. If a question is tagged with both interesting and ignored tags then it should be categorized as "interesting".

share|improve this answer

(duplicate answer)

Solution proposal

In my opinion the real solution would be to merge the two separate interesting and ignore lists into one single list. Each element then has the property of either interesting or ignore and the order of the elements gives priority, with the highest matching item "winning".

Example 1

Linux user that normally wants to ignore windows/macintosh, but not for questions about writing portable code:

  • unix: interesting
  • linux: interesting
  • portability: interesting
  • windows: ignore
  • machos: ignore

Example 2

Windows user that normally ignores unix/linux, but has a special interest in security and would like to read unix/linux questions related to that.

  • windows: interesting
  • security: interesting
  • unix: ignore
  • linux: ignore

Example 3

User with no interest in any questions related to php whatsoever.

  • php: ignore
  • java: interesting
  • something-else: interesting
  • boring-stuff: ignore

This would give a much better control to the users of which questions to ignore or include.

share|improve this answer

For those greasily inclined, I've updated my interesting/ignored tags greasemonkey script to support this feature. Now questions with "interesting" tags are always shown even if they're also tagged with an "ignored" tag, regardless of your "Hide Ignored Tags" setting (but keeps them faded out so you can still see they're "ignored").

share|improve this answer

I agree.

However, I'd add that I would like to see the questions which have both tags as they are rendered without the "Hide Ignored Tags" checkbox - Colored background and semitransparent. Don't simply make all favorite tagged questions show up as favorites, regardless of their ignored tag status.

share|improve this answer

I disagree.

Hidden tags are usually topics in which the user doesn't have any expertise, no matter if the question has an additional interesting tag.

Further, hiding questions improve the system! You can only look at a fixed amount of questions, by hiding questions the chances of seeing a question you actually can answer are increased. Showing questions both with hidden and interesting tags leads to more noise on the questions page.

If you really want that feature, write a script yourself. The hiding / highlighting of questions is completely done by client-side javascript.

share|improve this answer
6  
Tagging isn't perfect. I'd like to get questions tagged C#+image-recognition (even though I ignore C#) because the language is unlikely to have much to do with the problem. As for whipping up a script, not all SO users are web jockies. –  ergosys Jan 25 '10 at 20:34
    
I see no reason for you to disagree as it wouldn't affect you. –  Arlen Beiler Jan 26 '10 at 13:21
1  
@Arlen: 1. The SO team has only limited time, they should invest it where it's necessary. 2. I'd argue that less settings are preferable. The simpler the better. –  Georg Schölly Jan 26 '10 at 18:01
1  
It isn't our worry whether they have time or not. Our worry is that tags of interest won't show up if they are ignored. And like we said before, this would be an option. –  Arlen Beiler Jan 26 '10 at 18:26

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .