What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 134 Stack Exchange communities.

After running into this question on the Legendary badge, I remembered quite clearly there was a discussion about the calculation and its delay, but I searched through the [legendary] tag to no avail. Thinking I was dreaming about it, I decided to leave it for official statement... until S.Mark posted the question I had been thinking about. No wonder I never found it: it was tagged [epic]!

In general, there's no need to distinguish between these badges in the tags. In reviewing all of the questions tagged with [epic] or [legendary] (excepting Troggy's "epic" gravatar question, the actual content of the answers and the questions is the same, just with 50 days versus 150. In some cases they're referred to in pairs, and in general they exist as a pair for nearly any question that could be asked about them. So all keeping two separate tags does is divide the results, especially since some of those posts already have 5 tags.

Other examples of sets of badges which we actually have questions for include Good/Nice/Great Question, Good/Nice/Great Answer, and Popular/Notable/Famous Question.

So, given all this, what are your thoughts towards phrasing for compound badge tags on Meta? We can't have a slash in tags, so we can't do something like [epic/legendary]. Some possible options...

  • [epic-legendary] - Standard hyphen-concatenation.
  • [epic-legendary-badges] - Most badge tags are implied by virtue of the badges (like [pundit]), but if you pair two together it might help to include the word "badges".
  • [epic-and-legendary] - Kinda unwieldy sounding but an option nonetheless.

EDIT

Well, Jeff went ahead and made the decision to pick simple hyphen-concatenation for compound tag badges. We've still got some days left for the bounty, so I'll wait until then before accepting an answer, in case anyone else wants to say a few words.

share|improve this question
    
Also Enthusiast/Fanatic. –  mmyers May 21 '10 at 15:08
    
I did this three days ago. Didn't occur to me to ask a separate question about it. –  Pops May 21 '10 at 15:13
    
Actually, Mortarboard also, for 1 day rep-cap, but Mortarboard looks bug clean :) –  YOU May 21 '10 at 15:31

2 Answers 2

up vote 0 down vote accepted
+200

This is an exceedingly minor issue, but I merged them into [epic-legendary]

share|improve this answer
1  
What about, say, [enthusiast-fanatic]? Or questions that applied to only Epic and not Legendary? I thank you for taking action, but it seems you missed the larger issue while focusing on the specific example. –  Pops May 28 '10 at 2:52

I don't see the need for [epic-legendary] or the other "compound" tags you mention. If you're discussing the [daily-reputation-limit] (I'd have named it [rep-cap], but *shrug*), then that seems a better tag than either of the badge tags or some amalgamation.

I have run into the 5 tag limit more than once, however, and increasing that also solves this problem (given questions can be tagged/retagged with both as relevant).

share|improve this answer
    
I'm not speaking of the [reputation-cap] itself, I'm targetting the tag badges that are used to describe issues with badges themselves. Or are you suggesting that we be rid of all of the badge-specific tags? How would you tag a question about how one didn't receive the Legendary badge? –  Grace Note May 27 '10 at 11:47

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .