What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 133 Stack Exchange communities.

We have an [odd] problem on Stack Overflow. There are only 7 6 questions currently with this tag, but it covers 3 possible meanings and one of them I believe is undesirable. The last one is one I'm not sure how to take care of, hence bringing this up for discussion. The first two are merely around to establish the ambiguity of a plain "odd" tag.

1. Oddness

Only one question used the tag in this fashion, and I have already removed it. Considering the rally of support behind removing tags like [weird] and [strange], it made sense to get rid of it just like I plan to tackle the rest of its brethren like [odd-behaviour].

2. Quantities/Values Not Divisible By Two

Two questions use odd to refer to odd numbers. We could probably solve this with [odd-numbers] or [odd-number]. Very simple and meshes well with the existing numeric tags.

3. Alternating Elements of an Iteration

The meat of this question is the questions that use [odd] for this. Basically, when people want "every other element" of something. Sometimes it specifically is the odd-numbered iterations, but not all of them. Considering the lack of an "even" tag, I imagine those are tagged "odd" just because it was around.

I can't think of a proper tag for this concept, though. What are your thoughts?

share|improve this question
There's also [scanner](stackoverflow.com/questions/tagged/scanner) which I've seen used for both the optical kind (barcode scanner etc) and String scanning (java.util.Scanner). –  polygenelubricants Jun 1 '10 at 19:40
Related (should help you): meta.stackexchange.com/questions/50218/… –  Jon Seigel Jun 1 '10 at 19:51
@polygene I would actually recommend opening a separate question about that ambiguous tag. I'd like to keep this post's focus on [odd] –  Grace Note Jun 1 '10 at 20:16
Very late comment, I know, but I just checked and [scanner] is no longer used on SO. –  Pops Sep 28 '11 at 16:51
Two questions for meaning 2? That's very ... odd. –  Andrew Grimm Oct 26 '11 at 23:07

1 Answer 1

up vote 0 down vote accepted

Getting every odd variable in a list? [number] [odd]
Wanted to tag [beginner], but that's a meta-tag, and I'm trying to use less of those. The list manipulation just didn't seem significant enough for [list], [list-manipulation], or similar.

addClass every nth [odd] [alt] [alternate-elements]
The tag [alternate] could be a verb or a noun and ambiguous that way and [alternates] seems more "alternatives", otherwise I would've used it instead of [alternate-elements]. The tag [alt] only has 14 other uses, but every one of them refers to the alt attribute of <img> or the alt key on keyboards.

How to test if an array contains a pair of numbers whose product is odd? [odd] [learning] [beginner]
While [beginner] is a meta-tag like [learning], that question has already gone through discussion on it, and [beginner] at least has an aspect of tagging the question rather than the OP's motivation.

How to remove every other line? [odd] [line] [alternate-elements]

How to fill one UItableViewCell with odd and even entries from an NSMutableArray? [odd] [alternate-elements]

Optimize code performance when odd/even threads are doing different things in CUDA [odd]

share|improve this answer

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .