Yay! It works now (for me)...I just kept clicking through the links, and eventually it worked...I feel like a crazy person. But, apparently at least on other is seeing this behavior.
They just take you to a generic error page.
The following is the link to the top voted on-topic question, it is broken for me:
Also, the tab to go look at the discussion phase is also broken.
Update: I switched browsers to Internet Explorer. I had never been to Area 51 in IE. The links worked while I was not logged in, but after I logged in, they broke in IE as well.
It works logged out in chrome, and then breaks again when I log back in.