What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 127 Stack Exchange communities.

These questions were voted down I suppose for being inappropriate for the site because they were too broad or subjective. But shouldn't we have some off-topic questions like this to show new users what they shouldn't do?

  1. English Language & Usage: What are the top 5 things you hate about the english language?

  2. Game Development: Should I concentrate on implementing mouse/keyboard control or better gamepad control?

  3. English Language & Usage: Were Shakespeare's plays really written by Francis Bacon?

  4. Statistical Analysis: Where can I get a job as a statistician?

EDIT: @Robert, ok that makes sense. But to check my understanding, does it mean these questions are NOT good off-topic examples (even though they have been voted so) and are bad proposal questions overall?

cycling: what's good music to cycle to?

white hat SEO: should google allow paid links?

Apple: Why does Apple have such onerous rules about the ipad and ipod?

Gadgets: Will Apple produce an iPhone or iPod Touch with an Intel chip?


And that these are bad example questions for being spam?

white hat SEO: Can people please link to [sitename] so my PR goes up?

English language: Please help me to write an official meeting invitation email.

share|improve this question

closed as off-topic by Łukasz 웃 L ツ, Mołot, Martijn Pieters, hims056, Hugo Dozois Jan 31 at 16:19

This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:

  • "The problem described here can no longer be reproduced. Changes to the system or to the circumstances affecting the asker have rendered it obsolete. If you encounter a similar problem, please post a new question." – Łukasz 웃 L ツ, Martijn Pieters, hims056, Hugo Dozois
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

    
add comment

1 Answer

These questions were voted down ... because they were too broad or subjective. But shouldn't we have some off-topic questions like this to show new users what they shouldn't do?

No. Common mistake. [Closed as subjective] examples don't tell you anything about the site.

Don't confuse the reasons to close a question with whether a question is on- or off- topic. Those off-topic questions are supposed to tell you what the site is not about... What questions would be [closed as off-topic].

Most people are "getting" this because the voting results have been pretty darn good. But on occasion, I still see some confusion between "great off-topic example" and simply a bad question. I am working on a blog post to help clarify, but let me see how much I can emphasize this point:

The fact that a sample question is too broad or too subjective is a terrible, terrible, terrible reason to vote the question as a "great off-topic example."

It does nothing to help you define your subject space, and even worse, it will likely mislead your audience. Let me illustrate with an example (I am totally making this up):

SITE PROPOSAL

Topic: Coffee ... for professional drinkers and grinders of coffee.

(supposedly) great off-topic example: "Which is better, cappuccino or espresso?"

Obviously, this question would be [closed as subjective]... but is it an EXEMPLARY off-topic question? Let's pretend it was voted as the perfect off-topic question and the site gets created. The coffee enthusiast sees your site and is going to decide "Whoa! That's my kinda site!"... or they aren't. They see the FAQ which now looks something like this:

Welcome to CoffeeOverflow. Blah, blah, blah.

This site is about:

  • How do I roast my own coffee beans?
  • What is the difference between a blade grinder and a burr grinder?
  • How finely should I grind for moka?

This site is NOT about:

  • Can coffee cause you to gain weight?
  • At which stores can I get Yemeni coffee beans?
  • Which is better cappuccino or espresso? ←—————— WTF?

For some crazy reason, this coffee site isn't about cappuccino and espresso. Buh-bye!

The off-topic questions are supposed to tell you what questions would be [closed as off-topic].

Subjective or overly broad questions may well be [closed as subjective] but that has absolutely nothing to do with defining the scope of your site!... that's an issue of moderation policy and nobody cares. Bad question.

Let me finish with some examples of some awesome off-topic questions:

  • For a site about "The Business of Stand-Up Comedy," you just know someone is going show up telling jokes.

    "So a priest, a rabbi and a duck sit down at a bar..." [a must-have off-topic question]

  • A site for "Professional Chefs," you just know some Internet drive-by is going to treat the site like one of the 10,000 other recipe exchanges out there.

    "What is a good recipe for brownies?" [dead, spot-on awesome off-topic question]

  • Superuser.com, a site about computer hardware and software

    "How do you merge your World of Warcraft and Battle.net accounts?" [100% awesome. Tells people there is an explicit prohibition against video game questions]

  • A site for "Digital Photography"

    "Where's a good place to buy a Canon EOS-1D Mark IV

I think most every site should have have a good off-topic question which explicitly prohibits general shopping advice.

share|improve this answer
    
Mmm, thanks for using my proposal. –  delete Jun 16 '10 at 23:58
4  
This is actually the best explanation I've read so far. –  Aarobot Jun 17 '10 at 2:29
    
@Robert What if the FAQ includes the reason why the question is off-topic? I.e. emphasizing that this site is not a discussion forum? –  Tobias Kienzler Jun 17 '10 at 8:35
2  
@Tobias, no stack exchange site is a discussion forum, so there's no point explicitly saying so in every proposal. It would be like adding an "offtopic" example like "8uY C43ap \/|4Gra" in order to indicate that spam is not allowed. –  Blorgbeard Jun 17 '10 at 10:57
1  
@Tobias: As @Blorgbeard said, there are lots of rules around "allowed content" (no spam, no nudity, no illegal content, no explicit language, no subjective, no dups, no off-topic, etc, etc). Those just do not have anything to do with defining the SCOPE of the site. –  Robert Cartaino Jun 17 '10 at 12:49
    
@Blorgbeard and Robert: Agreed –  Tobias Kienzler Jun 17 '10 at 13:19
    
@Robert (see question text for my comment) –  Gordon Gustafson Jun 18 '10 at 4:48
    
Note that this wasn't completely obvious at the beginning, so I intentionally spammed the proposals I followed with every kind of question that wasn't going to be allowed. Not just off-topic ones. Might be that more users did this. After this post, it won't happen again I think –  Ivo Flipse Jun 18 '10 at 6:24
5  
So "great off-topic example" should be "This is a perfectly good question, it just belongs somewhere else –  Richard Gadsden Sep 9 '10 at 15:37
    
@Richard Gadsden: Exactly. –  Robert Cartaino Sep 9 '10 at 15:47
add comment

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .