What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 128 Stack Exchange communities.

Say user A posts a comment, B replies harsh to it. A deletes the comment and C decides from B's reply that A deserves better and replies @A. Will A be notified?

If this is an open question: I need two volunteers, one (A) to post a comment to which I (B) will reply which (s)he then will delete. The second volunteer (C) will then deduce from my @reply A's username and also reply. A has to check back later to state whether (s)he was notified.

share|improve this question
    
[placeholder for a harsh reply @RalphRickenbach] :p –  Tobias Kienzler Sep 17 '10 at 8:26
    
So I should reply to @RalphRickenbach –  Barry Sep 17 '10 at 8:48
    
Thank you @Barry –  Tobias Kienzler Sep 17 '10 at 8:51
    
@Ralph btw, let's test whether B's reply is treated differently - did you receive 0,1 or 2 notifications? –  Tobias Kienzler Sep 17 '10 at 8:52
    
@Tobias and @Barry (fyi) - so far, 15 min after Tobias added his comment to me, I only got the notification of the first place [placeholder] comment. I wonder whether I get some notifications after my name is in the commenters list again now. I will let you know. –  malach Sep 17 '10 at 9:10
    
@Ralph - so you should get a notification from this comment. Which I would say is correct. If you delete a comment you are saying "exclude from any notifications" until you comment again. –  Barry Sep 17 '10 at 9:13
    
@Barry - sure did. –  malach Sep 17 '10 at 9:17
add comment

1 Answer 1

up vote 2 down vote accepted

As the experiment would show:

If a comment, whose commentator was referenced by @commentator in later comment, had deleted all of his comments before the new comment directed at him was issued, he will not be notified.

If the original commentator will issue another comment later, previously added comments directed at him will not cause a notification. All comments issued after this will, as expected, result in a notification again.

This is easy to explain, it seems:

the @commentator structure does only search commentators and OP of the post (question or answer respectively, whatever has been commented). Comments that get deleted are deleted indeed and therefore the commentator does not leave a trace and can't be found.

share|improve this answer
1  
I guess it's because deleted comments disappear so much into the void that only Jeff can read them. –  Tobias Kienzler Sep 17 '10 at 9:35
add comment

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .