What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 134 Stack Exchange communities.

It seems almost all requests to add tag category/hierarchy/organization/etc have been shot down.

I'm suggesting a different variety: automatically add the appropriate "category" tag(s) when the question is posted.

Here's an example for my personal interest, very similar to a previous answer: On SO there's swing tag, but many people (especially n00bs) use specific tags like jtable, jlabel, etc. without using the swing tag. It would be a huge pain, if not impossible, to add all JComponent subclasses to my interested tags and RSS feed.

Per ThePony's answer, moderators would try to merge/retag, but it obviously hasn't happened (at least not completed) with those JComponent tags.

So instead of imposing it on our dearly-beloved mods, why not let the engine do it automatically, so that whenever a question with only jtable is posted, add swing to it? Or at least it can suggest the category tag(s) to the user.

The tag categorization/hierarchy should be maintained by mods or with high rep users on the category tag (the swing tag in my case).

share|improve this question
2  
Duplicate of Could we make tags imply other tags? and even more of Auto assign language tags to questions based on other tags.. The problem I see is, "child" tags don't necessarily imply any relevance to their parent: plenty of jQuery questions aren't about JavaScript, plenty of C# questions aren't about the .NET libraries. This isn't a technical problem... See also: On guidelines to tagging and avoiding unnecessary tags. –  Shogging through the snow Sep 27 '10 at 16:55
1  
No and no. In my example, 1) jtable tag stays as is. It does NOT imply swing. Instead swing is automatically added (or at least suggested) to the question. 2) I did NOT suggest adding java. swing is a large and self-sufficient enough tag to stand on itself. Only St. Skeet can follow language tags. –  Geoffrey Zheng Sep 27 '10 at 18:47

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .