Please reopen this question:
- Nick Craver (correctly) voted to close this question because it should have been a 'Community Wiki'. Now it is a 'Community Wiki' so that should, at a minimum, nullify his vote.
- Many developers are asking the same question; and they're looking for convincing arguments in either direction. That's why this is an extremely worthwhile question and why it's precisely the type of content that makes SO so valuable and useful. Opinions voiced in this discussion might lead a developer to pursue a certain path (i.e. to learn ASP.NET MVC or not learn ASP.NET MVC).