What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 134 Stack Exchange communities.

Existing, already-answered question: Program for displaying network activity by each app for MacOSX

My own unanswered and closed question: Free program for displaying network bandwidth by each app for MacOSX

The answers to the existing question don't answer in any way the question I am interested in.

Now, I was told here that I just should start a bounty on the already answered question.

I just did that, and the bounty ended without helping me at all. The default when I don't specify any answer — giving it to the answer with the highest score — does not make sense. That answer does not help me at all. None of the answers do help me.

Now I wonder what I should do. I am still waiting for an answer to my question. My question still is closed. To get traction on it, I would have to start another bounty. I am very short with reputation on Super User, so I can't just always do that again and again.

To not lose the reputation senselessly for the first bounty, I thought I would make a dummy answer and give that dummy answer the reputation. That way, I could keep my question open with further bounties until really got answered. That didn't work for some reason. It seems I just lost the reputation. Was that a bug/problem or is this intended?

How should I handle this? Obviously I cannot just always open bounties again and again until I get an answer. So should I just ignore it and go on to another question/answer site where unanswered questions can stay open?

Or maybe the system should be fixed so I can get the reputation back from bounties that didn't get me an answer I wanted.

share|improve this question

2 Answers 2

Since this is becoming a storm in a teacup I am going to make this clear once and for all.

The questions was closed because it was a duplicate off another, and one difference in feature set does not make a question any less a duplicate.

When you set a bounty, you take the risk that someone would be able to provide an answer. Bounties are non refundable and assigning a bounty to your own answer voids the points and you loose them anyway, this is by design.

Considering that you did this, and the answers that were provided to your question before it was closed matches the answers to the question you set a bounty to, have you actually even remotely considered that what your looking for does not exist, and that it cannot be answered?

Also, considering that it only takes 10 good questions or 5 good answers to get back the 50 reputation you lost, is it really that hard to try and contribute further to the site and recuperate the reputation? I am fairly confident you would have made the reputation back already with more participation.

share|improve this answer
    
If the one question can be answered and my question can not be answered, isn't that an argument that they actually are not duplicates? Also, no body really gave that answer yet (that no such solution exists). That is really what I want to know actually. Because I was thinking about implementing it myself. Besides, I am more into contributing to SO than to SU because I can help out more in that area. So I thought of getting help on SU and helping on SO. I guess it doesn't really make sense that you pay with reputation anyway. –  Albert Nov 12 '10 at 21:39
    
Also, it is stupid that I have to give away reputation for asking a question in a totally stupid way. –  Albert Nov 12 '10 at 21:40

According to the comments and answers here, particularly waffles, once you set the bounty, you lose the rep. Period.

share|improve this answer

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .