What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 128 Stack Exchange communities.

If I downvote, I always get the "please add a comment explaining why blah blah" text. I think this is a bug because many times I will comment and then downvote. So the text is telling me to do what I just did.

share|improve this question
add comment

3 Answers 3

up vote 11 down vote accepted

After tonight's build, we'll be suppressing the "please consider adding a comment" popup if you have already commented on the post you're downvoting.

share|improve this answer
    
Thanks Jarrod!! –  M. Tibbits Jul 26 '11 at 2:18
add comment

This is the usual behavior i have grown in habit of seeing.

Yeah This is a bug which is caused by the feature of suggesting the user to Add a comment. I think the down vote event is not bound with comments and so it shows.

Flowing are my thoughts on this:

  • I believe it is always a good thing to show the user to add a comment because it could be that what user commented about could be an answer to someone Else's comment or to ask a question from the OP. So the computer has no idea weather the comment was for down-vote or some usual chatter with the OP. So it dosent seem like it could be implemented perfectly.

  • If the user is shown that always it will force the user to rethink his action and see it was worth down-vote and he should give a comment explaining the cause for down-vote.

  • Also if user has already mentioned the reason in comment that notification will force him to check whether his comment for cause is appropriate.

Overall it will improve the quality of comments and Justify the down-votes.

share|improve this answer
    
Well, I'd say all your points are valid, except for the "please comment" box goes away after reaching a certain amount of reputation. So your points are moot in my opinion –  Earlz Feb 6 '11 at 2:55
    
Umm i havent seen that behavior with certain amount yet...but as i said it is a bug as it looks like the Notification feature is not bound to comment system.. –  Shekhar_Pro Feb 6 '11 at 2:57
add comment

It does not say "please add", it says "remember you can."

And the intent here is just as a reminder, it does not know or care if you actually left a comment.

This reminder goes away at 1k or 2k rep as I recall, so.. get more rep! :)

share|improve this answer
3  
It's still annoying :) –  Earlz Feb 6 '11 at 4:44
    
The rep requirement does not appear to be relaxed on the beta sites (as so many of them were.) I have ~1300 rep on the sqa beta, and it still appears. I, too, find it annoying. It seems silly to remind someone they can do something that they have already done. I feel this is more status-easiertocode than status-bydesign (which is, in my opinion, still a completely valid reason, as you must always weigh practical cost against the endless list of incoming feature requests, but it's still an important subset of 'by design.') –  corsiKa May 19 '11 at 23:34
5  
It's super annoying to comment, downvote, and then be asked to comment. The explanation that it "doesn't know" if you left a comment is simply elaborating on the bug report. It should know. When I upvote answers it knows if I've been voting on questions. Heck, when I upvote a comment it knows I upvoted another comment less than 5 seconds ago. So please, can it deign to know that I commented right before I downvoted? I would really like that. –  Kate Gregory Jul 24 '11 at 23:47
2  
@kate good point, we should probably check in that case. Will see if we can add that. –  Jeff Atwood Jul 24 '11 at 23:57
add comment

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .