What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 128 Stack Exchange communities.

I can't find anywhere in the FAQ that tells me how to use flags. I'm trying to be a good community member by flagging, and yes, a higher flag-weight does give me a warm fuzzy feeling.

So far, I've been using flags for spam, but I'm not sure when to flag something as "low quality" or "doesn't belong here". Here on meta, some people have suggested that low quality answers deserve close votes instead of flags, but as far as I can see, I don't have that privilege.

Can somebody point me either to answer on meta, or an FAQ page, that shows me when to use which flag and the etiquette involved in flagging.

share|improve this question
1  
I think the flags are pretty much self-explanatory. Do you have a specific question with an example? Also, flags like Noise, Low Quality and Offensive are of course objective, if you feel like one of these flags are necessary, flag it. –  Time Traveling Bobby May 3 '11 at 15:50
    
Offensive is easy - if someone is swearing or getting personal, it's offensive. Noise and low quality are much harder to define, and it varies depending on whether it's an answer or a comment. –  Blowski May 3 '11 at 16:36

2 Answers 2

up vote 13 down vote accepted

This is a very useful Q&A: To flag or not to flag and a request for auditing.

I've read a few different answers and tried to pull the info together. So from what I can see, and please correct me where I'm wrong:

Always flag

Flagging Questions

When to flag

  • The question is impossible to read - either because the English or formatting are so bad. If it's hard - but still possible - to understand try to edit instead of flagging.
  • It has absolutely nothing to do with StackOverflow - "What shall I name my cat?" type questions.
  • Duplicate questions - only where they are exact duplicates. If you are unsure, it's probably similar but not duplicate, so just post a comment with a link.

When not to flag

  • You think the question is silly, but still relevant to SO - "Since I'm only a small website, I don't need to secure inputs, right?". Just downvote it instead of flagging.
  • It's on-topic, but there is a more specific SO site - "How do I do this with Wordpress?". You can just leave a comment suggesting that they will get a better and quicker answer on wordpress.stackexchange.com.
  • Similar questions - link to the similar question in a comment.

Flagging Answers

When to flag

  • Obviously not even an attempt at an answer - "Thanks" or "Yeah, me too".

When not to flag

  • A bad answer (i.e. one that you disagree with) - "Security is irrelevant" deserves a downvote and a comment, not a flag
  • Doesn't answer the OP's question - "You asked this, but you want this instead." or just "This is a really bad idea and here's a list of reasons why". Downvote and comment if you think it deserves it, but don't flag.
  • Answer includes a link with no context, but the link is relevant and not obviously spam. Edit the answer or comment to give the link context. Are answers that just contain links elsewhere really "good answers"?

Flagging comments

How do comment voting and flagging work?

When to flag

  • Obviously spam or offensive

When not to flag

  • 'Me too' and 'thanks' type comments and mostly irrelevant comments - SO automatically hides them anyway. There are bigger fish to fry.
  • Comments that would be better as an answer - just suggest the commenter moves it to an answer instead without flagging
  • Every comment in a conversation - just flag the first one, and leave the mod to read the rest Add possibility to remove comment noise (fancy edition)
share|improve this answer
    
Pretty sure 'Me too' and 'thanks' type comments are ones you want to flag. They aren't magically removed, they have to accumulate 5(?) flags and are removed without manual intervention. I may be wrong, as I have seen mods jump in to posts where I flagged comments, but this could be due to the volume of flagging in a short time on that particular post. –  Wesley Murch May 3 '11 at 16:41
    
I took that from meta.stackexchange.com/questions/83480/… which seemed like if noisy comments were flagged, mods would be overloaded. –  Blowski May 3 '11 at 16:49

You can find a few posts about how flagging works in the FAQ for StackExchange Sites under the "Moderation" section.

share|improve this answer

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .