I was wondering when a comment should be flagged as "too chatty" vs "off-topic"?
I ask because I had the situation where an acquaintance posted the following comment (or something like it) to a question I had edited:
@Keoki long time no see!
Obviously this comment does nothing to help improve the question or provide an answer, and contributes nothing to the site. So it seems to me to be "off-topic". But it also seems to be "chatty". In this case, does it matter whether I flag the comment using one or the other categorization? Are they both equally valid?
When would a "too chatty" comment not also be "off-topic"?
Because I thought it would be useful, I found a post that explains What are valid reasons for flagging comments? in the first place.