What is meta? ×
Meta Stack Exchange is where users like you discuss bugs, features, and support issues that affect the software powering all 130 Stack Exchange communities.

A question can only have a max of 5 tags. Does it make sense to always go by "the more tags the better" even when some of chosen tags are:

  • barely related to the subject;
  • extremely detailed
  • very unpopular (0 followers).
  • and question already has 1 or more tags which describe it well?

I'm talking about situations when question has 1 or more well-suited tags, and the rest don't have a real purpose (in my opinion).

Examples:

Fixed panels while scrolling on a centered design This css related question has fixed tag. Should this tag be removed from the question? Technically, a tag could be created for each css attribute, each php function... See where I'm going?

Another example would be mysql_real_escape_string tag for php/mysql related question.

error tag. How can this tag be useful? It doesn't tell anything.

css3-transitions-not-working-on-button css-transitions tag used here. Should it be kept or removed?

In all situations mentioned above, I would opt for removing the bolded tag. But maybe my understanding of tagging questions is wrong.

I found a similar question (should-imprecise-tags-be-removed), but it's not as detailed as I'd wish.

Shed some light/share your thoughts :)

share|improve this question
1  
AAAAAAA! mysql-real-escape-string is a real thing!? For Pete's sake. –  Charles Jul 1 '11 at 20:05

1 Answer 1

up vote 6 down vote accepted

Improper tagging usually falls under:

  1. Unnecessary, extraneous tags (like on the MySQL question).
  2. Improper tag due to shared nomenclature (your example or on a WPF question).
  3. "Meta" tags.

Extraneous tags should be removed, improper tags should be removed, and "meta" tags should be removed.

Now in the case of , it may be worthwhile letting it ride to see if enough questions pop up regarding CSS Transitions.

share|improve this answer
    
Why should 'Extraneous' tags be removed? If they are not relevant, its understandable, but if they are relevant... (This also depends on the varying opinion of which tags are extraneous...) –  Wilf Jul 22 at 14:36

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .