3 replaced http://stackoverflow.com/ with https://stackoverflow.com/
source | link

I've noticed that some people feel like a vote to close is tantamount to saying "this is a bad question", which (edge cases aside) isn't usually true; when I vote to close, it usually means "this question isn't right for this stack exchange"

For example, consider the question http://stackoverflow.com/questions/6964909/how-to-read-key-in-span-using-java-scriptHow do I read an attribute of a HTML tag using JavaScript? and the comment thread. It's a fine question: clear, simple, etc. It's just too specific for Stack Overflow (at least according to the current definition of "too localized").

I feel like it would be a good thing if the distinction between "downvote because this is a bad question" and "vote to close because this question isn't right for Stack Overflow" was made clear for the applicable "vote to close" options.

I've noticed that some people feel like a vote to close is tantamount to saying "this is a bad question", which (edge cases aside) isn't usually true; when I vote to close, it usually means "this question isn't right for this stack exchange"

For example, consider the question http://stackoverflow.com/questions/6964909/how-to-read-key-in-span-using-java-script and the comment thread. It's a fine question: clear, simple, etc. It's just too specific for Stack Overflow (at least according to the current definition of "too localized").

I feel like it would be a good thing if the distinction between "downvote because this is a bad question" and "vote to close because this question isn't right for Stack Overflow" was made clear for the applicable "vote to close" options.

I've noticed that some people feel like a vote to close is tantamount to saying "this is a bad question", which (edge cases aside) isn't usually true; when I vote to close, it usually means "this question isn't right for this stack exchange"

For example, consider the question How do I read an attribute of a HTML tag using JavaScript? and the comment thread. It's a fine question: clear, simple, etc. It's just too specific for Stack Overflow (at least according to the current definition of "too localized").

I feel like it would be a good thing if the distinction between "downvote because this is a bad question" and "vote to close because this question isn't right for Stack Overflow" was made clear for the applicable "vote to close" options.

2 deleted 3 characters in body
source | link

I've noticed that some people feel like a vote to close is tantamount to saying “this"this is a bad question”… Whichquestion", edgewhich (edge cases aside,) isn't usually true; when I vote to close, it usually means “this"this question isn't right for this stack exchange”.exchange"

For example, consider the question http://stackoverflow.com/questions/6964909/how-to-read-key-in-span-using-java-script and the comment thread. It's a fine question: clear, simple, etc — it's. It's just too specific for Stack Overflow (at least according to the current definition of “too localized”"too localized").

I feel like it would be a Good Thinggood thing if the distinction between “downvote"downvote because this is a bad question”question" and “vote"vote to close because this question isn't right for Stack Overflow”Overflow" was made clear for the applicable “vote"vote to close”close" options.

I've noticed that some people feel like a vote to close is tantamount to saying “this is a bad question”… Which, edge cases aside, isn't usually true; when I vote to close, it usually means “this question isn't right for this stack exchange”.

For example, consider the question http://stackoverflow.com/questions/6964909/how-to-read-key-in-span-using-java-script and the comment thread. It's a fine question clear, simple, etc — it's just too specific for Stack Overflow (at least according to the current definition of “too localized”).

I feel like it would be a Good Thing if the distinction between “downvote because this is a bad question” and “vote to close because this question isn't right for Stack Overflow” was made clear for the applicable “vote to close” options.

I've noticed that some people feel like a vote to close is tantamount to saying "this is a bad question", which (edge cases aside) isn't usually true; when I vote to close, it usually means "this question isn't right for this stack exchange"

For example, consider the question http://stackoverflow.com/questions/6964909/how-to-read-key-in-span-using-java-script and the comment thread. It's a fine question: clear, simple, etc. It's just too specific for Stack Overflow (at least according to the current definition of "too localized").

I feel like it would be a good thing if the distinction between "downvote because this is a bad question" and "vote to close because this question isn't right for Stack Overflow" was made clear for the applicable "vote to close" options.

1
source | link

Copy update to “vote to close” making it clear that a close vote isn't “bad”?

I've noticed that some people feel like a vote to close is tantamount to saying “this is a bad question”… Which, edge cases aside, isn't usually true; when I vote to close, it usually means “this question isn't right for this stack exchange”.

For example, consider the question http://stackoverflow.com/questions/6964909/how-to-read-key-in-span-using-java-script and the comment thread. It's a fine question — clear, simple, etc — it's just too specific for Stack Overflow (at least according to the current definition of “too localized”).

I feel like it would be a Good Thing if the distinction between “downvote because this is a bad question” and “vote to close because this question isn't right for Stack Overflow” was made clear for the applicable “vote to close” options.