8 replaced http://meta.stackexchange.com/ with https://meta.stackexchange.com/
source | link

Citizenship, to me, implies well-rounded-ness in the use of Stack Overflow. Not only do you ask questions, you accept answers, you write new answers, you edit, you review, etc.

So, what else is well-rounded? Delicious pie, of course! Or cake, if you prefer.

I propose showing a wheel on a user's profile, with wedges that are representative of the user's activity in a particular area of the site. Once you've performed some quantum of activity in that particular category, you are granted the wedge. A similar feature was introduced on Kickstarter last year, where you collect a wedge for supporting a project in each category. Classically, of course, it takes inspiration from collecting wedges in Trivial Pursuit.

You could use more saturated colours for higher activity levels in a category, or make it a simple binary. You could have a count on the number of activities in a wedge, for example, you wouldn't get the question wedge until you've asked a certain number of questions, or accepted answers for them, or upvoted/edited them, or earned a certain number of question-related badges, or some combination of all of the above.

I don't believe it would dilute the existing systems, as it would be more about displaying the existing badges/reputation gains in a more consolidated way (a meta-badge, if you will). For examples of categories, see the above list, or just about every other answer here.

I don't believe it would unfairly penalize active contributors, as I've rarely seen a contributor that hasn't asked a single question. Even so, there needn't be specific question and answer categories - a content category could cover both ways of contributing content to the site. Other answers with useful categories: badpbadp, lechlukaszlechlukasz, and even the original postoriginal post.

But most importantly, it would help give new users a sense of the broader goals of the site. The current collection of badges is fairly useful in that sense, but there is an overwhelming number of them, in alphabetical order. Which is fine if you're looking for criteria on a specific badge, but not so great if you're trying to find out which badges are for good answers (for example).

Citizenship, to me, implies well-rounded-ness in the use of Stack Overflow. Not only do you ask questions, you accept answers, you write new answers, you edit, you review, etc.

So, what else is well-rounded? Delicious pie, of course! Or cake, if you prefer.

I propose showing a wheel on a user's profile, with wedges that are representative of the user's activity in a particular area of the site. Once you've performed some quantum of activity in that particular category, you are granted the wedge. A similar feature was introduced on Kickstarter last year, where you collect a wedge for supporting a project in each category. Classically, of course, it takes inspiration from collecting wedges in Trivial Pursuit.

You could use more saturated colours for higher activity levels in a category, or make it a simple binary. You could have a count on the number of activities in a wedge, for example, you wouldn't get the question wedge until you've asked a certain number of questions, or accepted answers for them, or upvoted/edited them, or earned a certain number of question-related badges, or some combination of all of the above.

I don't believe it would dilute the existing systems, as it would be more about displaying the existing badges/reputation gains in a more consolidated way (a meta-badge, if you will). For examples of categories, see the above list, or just about every other answer here.

I don't believe it would unfairly penalize active contributors, as I've rarely seen a contributor that hasn't asked a single question. Even so, there needn't be specific question and answer categories - a content category could cover both ways of contributing content to the site. Other answers with useful categories: badp, lechlukasz, and even the original post.

But most importantly, it would help give new users a sense of the broader goals of the site. The current collection of badges is fairly useful in that sense, but there is an overwhelming number of them, in alphabetical order. Which is fine if you're looking for criteria on a specific badge, but not so great if you're trying to find out which badges are for good answers (for example).

Citizenship, to me, implies well-rounded-ness in the use of Stack Overflow. Not only do you ask questions, you accept answers, you write new answers, you edit, you review, etc.

So, what else is well-rounded? Delicious pie, of course! Or cake, if you prefer.

I propose showing a wheel on a user's profile, with wedges that are representative of the user's activity in a particular area of the site. Once you've performed some quantum of activity in that particular category, you are granted the wedge. A similar feature was introduced on Kickstarter last year, where you collect a wedge for supporting a project in each category. Classically, of course, it takes inspiration from collecting wedges in Trivial Pursuit.

You could use more saturated colours for higher activity levels in a category, or make it a simple binary. You could have a count on the number of activities in a wedge, for example, you wouldn't get the question wedge until you've asked a certain number of questions, or accepted answers for them, or upvoted/edited them, or earned a certain number of question-related badges, or some combination of all of the above.

I don't believe it would dilute the existing systems, as it would be more about displaying the existing badges/reputation gains in a more consolidated way (a meta-badge, if you will). For examples of categories, see the above list, or just about every other answer here.

I don't believe it would unfairly penalize active contributors, as I've rarely seen a contributor that hasn't asked a single question. Even so, there needn't be specific question and answer categories - a content category could cover both ways of contributing content to the site. Other answers with useful categories: badp, lechlukasz, and even the original post.

But most importantly, it would help give new users a sense of the broader goals of the site. The current collection of badges is fairly useful in that sense, but there is an overwhelming number of them, in alphabetical order. Which is fine if you're looking for criteria on a specific badge, but not so great if you're trying to find out which badges are for good answers (for example).

7 Migration of MSO links to MSE links
source | link

Citizenship, to me, implies well-rounded-ness in the use of Stack Overflow. Not only do you ask questions, you accept answers, you write new answers, you edit, you review, etc.

So, what else is well-rounded? Delicious pie, of course! Or cake, if you prefer.

I propose showing a wheel on a user's profile, with wedges that are representative of the user's activity in a particular area of the site. Once you've performed some quantum of activity in that particular category, you are granted the wedge. A similar feature was introduced on Kickstarter last year, where you collect a wedge for supporting a project in each category. Classically, of course, it takes inspiration from collecting wedges in Trivial Pursuit.

You could use more saturated colours for higher activity levels in a category, or make it a simple binary. You could have a count on the number of activities in a wedge, for example, you wouldn't get the question wedge until you've asked a certain number of questions, or accepted answers for them, or upvoted/edited them, or earned a certain number of question-related badges, or some combination of all of the above.

I don't believe it would dilute the existing systems, as it would be more about displaying the existing badges/reputation gains in a more consolidated way (a meta-badge, if you will). For examples of categories, see the above list, or just about every other answer here.

I don't believe it would unfairly penalize active contributors, as I've rarely seen a contributor that hasn't asked a single question. Even so, there needn't be specific question and answer categories - a content category could cover both ways of contributing content to the site. Other answers with useful categories: badpbadp, lechlukaszlechlukasz, and even the original postoriginal post.

But most importantly, it would help give new users a sense of the broader goals of the site. The current collection of badges is fairly useful in that sense, but there is an overwhelming number of them, in alphabetical order. Which is fine if you're looking for criteria on a specific badge, but not so great if you're trying to find out which badges are for good answers (for example).

Citizenship, to me, implies well-rounded-ness in the use of Stack Overflow. Not only do you ask questions, you accept answers, you write new answers, you edit, you review, etc.

So, what else is well-rounded? Delicious pie, of course! Or cake, if you prefer.

I propose showing a wheel on a user's profile, with wedges that are representative of the user's activity in a particular area of the site. Once you've performed some quantum of activity in that particular category, you are granted the wedge. A similar feature was introduced on Kickstarter last year, where you collect a wedge for supporting a project in each category. Classically, of course, it takes inspiration from collecting wedges in Trivial Pursuit.

You could use more saturated colours for higher activity levels in a category, or make it a simple binary. You could have a count on the number of activities in a wedge, for example, you wouldn't get the question wedge until you've asked a certain number of questions, or accepted answers for them, or upvoted/edited them, or earned a certain number of question-related badges, or some combination of all of the above.

I don't believe it would dilute the existing systems, as it would be more about displaying the existing badges/reputation gains in a more consolidated way (a meta-badge, if you will). For examples of categories, see the above list, or just about every other answer here.

I don't believe it would unfairly penalize active contributors, as I've rarely seen a contributor that hasn't asked a single question. Even so, there needn't be specific question and answer categories - a content category could cover both ways of contributing content to the site. Other answers with useful categories: badp, lechlukasz, and even the original post.

But most importantly, it would help give new users a sense of the broader goals of the site. The current collection of badges is fairly useful in that sense, but there is an overwhelming number of them, in alphabetical order. Which is fine if you're looking for criteria on a specific badge, but not so great if you're trying to find out which badges are for good answers (for example).

Citizenship, to me, implies well-rounded-ness in the use of Stack Overflow. Not only do you ask questions, you accept answers, you write new answers, you edit, you review, etc.

So, what else is well-rounded? Delicious pie, of course! Or cake, if you prefer.

I propose showing a wheel on a user's profile, with wedges that are representative of the user's activity in a particular area of the site. Once you've performed some quantum of activity in that particular category, you are granted the wedge. A similar feature was introduced on Kickstarter last year, where you collect a wedge for supporting a project in each category. Classically, of course, it takes inspiration from collecting wedges in Trivial Pursuit.

You could use more saturated colours for higher activity levels in a category, or make it a simple binary. You could have a count on the number of activities in a wedge, for example, you wouldn't get the question wedge until you've asked a certain number of questions, or accepted answers for them, or upvoted/edited them, or earned a certain number of question-related badges, or some combination of all of the above.

I don't believe it would dilute the existing systems, as it would be more about displaying the existing badges/reputation gains in a more consolidated way (a meta-badge, if you will). For examples of categories, see the above list, or just about every other answer here.

I don't believe it would unfairly penalize active contributors, as I've rarely seen a contributor that hasn't asked a single question. Even so, there needn't be specific question and answer categories - a content category could cover both ways of contributing content to the site. Other answers with useful categories: badp, lechlukasz, and even the original post.

But most importantly, it would help give new users a sense of the broader goals of the site. The current collection of badges is fairly useful in that sense, but there is an overwhelming number of them, in alphabetical order. Which is fine if you're looking for criteria on a specific badge, but not so great if you're trying to find out which badges are for good answers (for example).

6 broader goals back in
source | link

Citizenship, to me, implies well-rounded-ness in the use of Stack Overflow.Citizenship, to me, implies well-rounded-ness in the use of Stack Overflow. Not only do you ask questions, you accept answers, you write new answers, you edit, you review, etc.

So, what else is well-rounded? Delicious pie, of course! Or cake, if you prefer.

I propose showing a pie wheel on a user's profile, where a wedge is representative of the user's activity in a particular area of the site.I propose showing a wheel on a user's profile, with wedges that are representative of the user's activity in a particular area of the site. Once you've performed some quantum of activity in that particular category, you are granted the wedge. A similar feature was introduced on Kickstarter last year, where you collect a wedge for supporting a project in each category. Classically, of course, it takes inspiration from collecting wedges in Trivial Pursuit.

You could use more saturated colours for higher activity levels in a category, or make it a simple binary. You could have a count on the number of activities in a wedge, for example, you wouldn't get the question wedge until you've asked a certain number of questions, or accepted answers for them, or upvoted/edited them, or earned a certain number of question-related badges, or some combination of all of the above.

I don't believe it would dilute the existing systems, as it would be more about displaying the existing badges/reputation gains in a more consolidated way (a meta-badge, if you will). For examples of categories, see the above list, or just about every other answer here.

I don't believe it would unfairly penalize active contributors, as I've rarely seen a contributor that hasn't asked a single question. Even so, there needn't be specific question and answer categories - a content category could cover both ways of contributing content to the site. Other answers with useful categories: badp, lechlukasz, and even the original post.

But most importantly, it would help give new users a sense of the broader goals of the site. The current collection of badges is fairly useful in that sense, but there is an overwhelming number of them, in alphabetical order. Which is fine if you're looking for criteria on a specific badge, but not so great if you're trying to find out which badges are for good answers (for example).

Citizenship, to me, implies well-rounded-ness in the use of Stack Overflow. Not only do you ask questions, you accept answers, you write new answers, you edit, you review, etc.

So, what else is well-rounded? Delicious pie, of course! Or cake, if you prefer.

I propose showing a pie wheel on a user's profile, where a wedge is representative of the user's activity in a particular area of the site. Once you've performed some quantum of activity in that particular category, you are granted the wedge. A similar feature was introduced on Kickstarter last year, where you collect a wedge for supporting a project in each category. Classically, of course, it takes inspiration from collecting wedges in Trivial Pursuit.

You could use more saturated colours for higher activity levels in a category, or make it a simple binary. You could have a count on the number of activities in a wedge, for example, you wouldn't get the question wedge until you've asked a certain number of questions, or accepted answers for them, or upvoted/edited them, or earned a certain number of question-related badges, or some combination of all of the above.

I don't believe it would dilute the existing systems, as it would be more about displaying the existing badges/reputation gains in a more consolidated way (a meta-badge, if you will). For examples of categories, see the above list, or just about every other answer here.

I don't believe it would unfairly penalize active contributors, as I've rarely seen a contributor that hasn't asked a single question. Even so, there needn't be specific question and answer categories - a content category could cover both ways of contributing content to the site. Other answers with useful categories: badp lechlukasz

Citizenship, to me, implies well-rounded-ness in the use of Stack Overflow. Not only do you ask questions, you accept answers, you write new answers, you edit, you review, etc.

So, what else is well-rounded? Delicious pie, of course! Or cake, if you prefer.

I propose showing a wheel on a user's profile, with wedges that are representative of the user's activity in a particular area of the site. Once you've performed some quantum of activity in that particular category, you are granted the wedge. A similar feature was introduced on Kickstarter last year, where you collect a wedge for supporting a project in each category. Classically, of course, it takes inspiration from collecting wedges in Trivial Pursuit.

You could use more saturated colours for higher activity levels in a category, or make it a simple binary. You could have a count on the number of activities in a wedge, for example, you wouldn't get the question wedge until you've asked a certain number of questions, or accepted answers for them, or upvoted/edited them, or earned a certain number of question-related badges, or some combination of all of the above.

I don't believe it would dilute the existing systems, as it would be more about displaying the existing badges/reputation gains in a more consolidated way (a meta-badge, if you will). For examples of categories, see the above list, or just about every other answer here.

I don't believe it would unfairly penalize active contributors, as I've rarely seen a contributor that hasn't asked a single question. Even so, there needn't be specific question and answer categories - a content category could cover both ways of contributing content to the site. Other answers with useful categories: badp, lechlukasz, and even the original post.

But most importantly, it would help give new users a sense of the broader goals of the site. The current collection of badges is fairly useful in that sense, but there is an overwhelming number of them, in alphabetical order. Which is fine if you're looking for criteria on a specific badge, but not so great if you're trying to find out which badges are for good answers (for example).

5 clarified other categories
source | link
4 further clarification
source | link
3 clarification of wedges
source | link
2 fleshing out
source | link
1
source | link