5 replaced http://stackoverflow.com/ with https://stackoverflow.com/
source | link

The question: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/17533607/travelling-by-busTravelling by bus

The comment above the close reason:

I voted to close not because the asker didn't know what he was asking, but because the question is a lightning rod for lunatic speculation about algorithms and complexity.

Surely this cannot be a valid reason to close?

The question: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/17533607/travelling-by-bus

The comment above the close reason:

I voted to close not because the asker didn't know what he was asking, but because the question is a lightning rod for lunatic speculation about algorithms and complexity.

Surely this cannot be a valid reason to close?

The question: Travelling by bus

The comment above the close reason:

I voted to close not because the asker didn't know what he was asking, but because the question is a lightning rod for lunatic speculation about algorithms and complexity.

Surely this cannot be a valid reason to close?

4 edited tags
| link
3 made it an actual question, adjusted formatting, tags, etc.
source | link

Is "Lunatic Speculation" as a reasonable reason to close Qa question with 18 upvotes, 5 answers, 5 stars?

See comments belowThe question: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/17533607/travelling-by-bus

The comment above the close reason:

"II voted to close not because the asker didn't know what he was asking, but because the question is a lightning rod for lunatic speculation about algorithms and complexity."

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/17533607/travelling-by-bus Surely this cannot be a valid reason to close?

"Lunatic Speculation" as a reason to close Q with 18 upvotes, 5 answers, 5 stars

See comments below question above close reason:

"I voted to close not because the asker didn't know what he was asking, but because the question is a lightning rod for lunatic speculation about algorithms and complexity."

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/17533607/travelling-by-bus

Is "Lunatic Speculation" a reasonable reason to close a question with 18 upvotes, 5 answers, 5 stars?

The question: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/17533607/travelling-by-bus

The comment above the close reason:

I voted to close not because the asker didn't know what he was asking, but because the question is a lightning rod for lunatic speculation about algorithms and complexity.

Surely this cannot be a valid reason to close?

2 added 3 characters in body; edited tags
source | link
1
source | link