2 added 11 characters in body
source | link

This is a valiant effort, but let me share my thoughts on why this wouldn't catch on so easily:

  • Old habits die hard - Many of the meta folks here are "old dogs", starting a new trend might be difficult at best.
  • People like to downvote - Let's face it, it's fun. Many people have a trigger happy finger when it comes to downvoting in general, and questions specifically.
  • There are no consequences for voting - Reputation isn't negatively affected by downvoting questions. In fact, on any other meta other than this one, there's no reputation change whatsoever, so even if you were uncomfortable with downvoting because you don't want OP's rep to be damaged, that doesn't exist anymore.

So the actions I would take:

  • No automatic question ban on meta - Why the hell does that even exist? If someone is abusive, suspend. If someone goes against the mainstream, we shut him down?
  • Reputation effect when voting on meta - Specifically, negative effects when downvoting questions on meta, just like on main sites on answers. It works well in making people think twice.

That in addition to the effort to re-educate people to not downvote questions they disagree with.

This is a valiant effort, but let me share my thoughts on why this wouldn't catch on so easily:

  • Old habits die hard - Many of the meta folks here are "old dogs", starting a new trend might be difficult at best.
  • People like to downvote - Let's face it, it's fun. Many people have a trigger happy finger when it comes to downvoting in general, and questions specifically.
  • There are no consequences - Reputation isn't negatively affected by downvoting questions. In fact, on any other meta other than this one, there's no reputation change whatsoever, so even if you were uncomfortable with downvoting because you don't want OP's rep to be damaged, that doesn't exist anymore.

So the actions I would take:

  • No automatic question ban on meta - Why the hell does that even exist? If someone is abusive, suspend. If someone goes against the mainstream, we shut him down?
  • Reputation effect when voting on meta - Specifically, negative effects when downvoting questions on meta, just like on main sites on answers. It works well in making people think twice.

That in addition to the effort to re-educate people to not downvote questions they disagree with.

This is a valiant effort, but let me share my thoughts on why this wouldn't catch on so easily:

  • Old habits die hard - Many of the meta folks here are "old dogs", starting a new trend might be difficult at best.
  • People like to downvote - Let's face it, it's fun. Many people have a trigger happy finger when it comes to downvoting in general, and questions specifically.
  • There are no consequences for voting - Reputation isn't negatively affected by downvoting questions. In fact, on any other meta other than this one, there's no reputation change whatsoever, so even if you were uncomfortable with downvoting because you don't want OP's rep to be damaged, that doesn't exist anymore.

So the actions I would take:

  • No automatic question ban on meta - Why the hell does that even exist? If someone is abusive, suspend. If someone goes against the mainstream, we shut him down?
  • Reputation effect when voting on meta - Specifically, negative effects when downvoting questions on meta, just like on main sites on answers. It works well in making people think twice.

That in addition to the effort to re-educate people to not downvote questions they disagree with.

1
source | link

This is a valiant effort, but let me share my thoughts on why this wouldn't catch on so easily:

  • Old habits die hard - Many of the meta folks here are "old dogs", starting a new trend might be difficult at best.
  • People like to downvote - Let's face it, it's fun. Many people have a trigger happy finger when it comes to downvoting in general, and questions specifically.
  • There are no consequences - Reputation isn't negatively affected by downvoting questions. In fact, on any other meta other than this one, there's no reputation change whatsoever, so even if you were uncomfortable with downvoting because you don't want OP's rep to be damaged, that doesn't exist anymore.

So the actions I would take:

  • No automatic question ban on meta - Why the hell does that even exist? If someone is abusive, suspend. If someone goes against the mainstream, we shut him down?
  • Reputation effect when voting on meta - Specifically, negative effects when downvoting questions on meta, just like on main sites on answers. It works well in making people think twice.

That in addition to the effort to re-educate people to not downvote questions they disagree with.