3 replaced http://meta.stackoverflow.com/ with https://meta.stackoverflow.com/
source | link

The criteria for the badge seems to be a great idea and I think it should be made into a badge.


Firstly, should this be a new badge?

Yes, I don't think that it should replace the existing Reversal badge. Though the flaws of the Reversal badge has been brought upflaws of the Reversal badge has been brought up, the idea of the current Reversal badge isn't necessarily bad.

As Tim Post pointed out in this answerthis answer,

It's occasionally awarded for someone giving a bit of a snarky answer to a poor question, but most that earn it worked hard for it once they saw an opportunity to get one.

Since the Reversal badge is awarded to the answerer, I don't think that there's anything wrong with occasional bad questions. The main purpose of Reversal is to reward and credit the effort of the answerer who tries to provide a good answer to "not so good" questions.


Secondly, should this be a gold, silver or bronze badge?

The hat of this criteria was the most difficult hat for all 3 Winter Bashes that includes it.

  • In 2014, this was a non-secret hat known as Red Baron and was awarded 26 times.
  • In 2015, this was a secret hat known as Flying Tiger and was awarded 11 times.
  • In 2016, this was a non-secret hat known as Maverick and was awarded 17 times.

So, this concludes that the new badge is quite difficult to earn. However, since it's slightly different from Reversal, I think it should be made a stand-alone gold badge.

It wouldn't make sense to make it a "silver version" of Reversal since a user can get Reversal but not this badge due to the "question later becomes +3" criteria.


So,

Image

The criteria for the badge seems to be a great idea and I think it should be made into a badge.


Firstly, should this be a new badge?

Yes, I don't think that it should replace the existing Reversal badge. Though the flaws of the Reversal badge has been brought up, the idea of the current Reversal badge isn't necessarily bad.

As Tim Post pointed out in this answer,

It's occasionally awarded for someone giving a bit of a snarky answer to a poor question, but most that earn it worked hard for it once they saw an opportunity to get one.

Since the Reversal badge is awarded to the answerer, I don't think that there's anything wrong with occasional bad questions. The main purpose of Reversal is to reward and credit the effort of the answerer who tries to provide a good answer to "not so good" questions.


Secondly, should this be a gold, silver or bronze badge?

The hat of this criteria was the most difficult hat for all 3 Winter Bashes that includes it.

  • In 2014, this was a non-secret hat known as Red Baron and was awarded 26 times.
  • In 2015, this was a secret hat known as Flying Tiger and was awarded 11 times.
  • In 2016, this was a non-secret hat known as Maverick and was awarded 17 times.

So, this concludes that the new badge is quite difficult to earn. However, since it's slightly different from Reversal, I think it should be made a stand-alone gold badge.

It wouldn't make sense to make it a "silver version" of Reversal since a user can get Reversal but not this badge due to the "question later becomes +3" criteria.


So,

Image

The criteria for the badge seems to be a great idea and I think it should be made into a badge.


Firstly, should this be a new badge?

Yes, I don't think that it should replace the existing Reversal badge. Though the flaws of the Reversal badge has been brought up, the idea of the current Reversal badge isn't necessarily bad.

As Tim Post pointed out in this answer,

It's occasionally awarded for someone giving a bit of a snarky answer to a poor question, but most that earn it worked hard for it once they saw an opportunity to get one.

Since the Reversal badge is awarded to the answerer, I don't think that there's anything wrong with occasional bad questions. The main purpose of Reversal is to reward and credit the effort of the answerer who tries to provide a good answer to "not so good" questions.


Secondly, should this be a gold, silver or bronze badge?

The hat of this criteria was the most difficult hat for all 3 Winter Bashes that includes it.

  • In 2014, this was a non-secret hat known as Red Baron and was awarded 26 times.
  • In 2015, this was a secret hat known as Flying Tiger and was awarded 11 times.
  • In 2016, this was a non-secret hat known as Maverick and was awarded 17 times.

So, this concludes that the new badge is quite difficult to earn. However, since it's slightly different from Reversal, I think it should be made a stand-alone gold badge.

It wouldn't make sense to make it a "silver version" of Reversal since a user can get Reversal but not this badge due to the "question later becomes +3" criteria.


So,

Image

2 Edited to clarify if the hat is a secret one
source | link

The criteria for the badge seems to be a great idea and I think it should be made into a badge.


Firstly, should this be a new badge?

Yes, I don't think that it should replace the existing Reversal badge. Though the flaws of the Reversal badge has been brought up, the idea of the current Reversal badge isn't necessarily bad.

As Tim Post pointed out in this answer,

It's occasionally awarded for someone giving a bit of a snarky answer to a poor question, but most that earn it worked hard for it once they saw an opportunity to get one.

Since the Reversal badge is awarded to the answerer, I don't think that there's anything wrong with occasional bad questions. The main purpose of Reversal is to reward and credit the effort of the answerer who tries to provide a good answer to "not so good" questions.


Secondly, should this be a gold, silver or bronze badge?

The hat of this criteria was the most difficult hat for all 3 Winter Bashes that includes it.

  • In 2014, thethis was a non-secret hat is known as Red Baron and was awarded 26 times.
  • In 2015, thethis was a secret hat is known as Flying Tiger and was awarded 11 times.
  • In 2016, thethis was a non-secret hat is known as Maverick and was awarded 17 times.

So, this concludes that the new badge is quite difficult to earn. However, since it's slightly different from Reversal, I think it should be made a stand-alone gold badge.

It wouldn't make sense to make it a "silver version" of Reversal since a user can get Reversal but not this badge due to the "question later becomes +3" criteria.


So,

Image

The criteria for the badge seems to be a great idea and I think it should be made into a badge.


Firstly, should this be a new badge?

Yes, I don't think that it should replace the existing Reversal badge. Though the flaws of the Reversal badge has been brought up, the idea of the current Reversal badge isn't necessarily bad.

As Tim Post pointed out in this answer,

It's occasionally awarded for someone giving a bit of a snarky answer to a poor question, but most that earn it worked hard for it once they saw an opportunity to get one.

Since the Reversal badge is awarded to the answerer, I don't think that there's anything wrong with occasional bad questions. The main purpose of Reversal is to reward and credit the effort of the answerer who tries to provide a good answer to "not so good" questions.


Secondly, should this be a gold, silver or bronze badge?

The hat of this criteria was the most difficult hat for all 3 Winter Bashes that includes it.

  • In 2014, the hat is known as Red Baron and was awarded 26 times.
  • In 2015, the hat is known as Flying Tiger and was awarded 11 times.
  • In 2016, the hat is known as Maverick and was awarded 17 times.

So, this concludes that the new badge is quite difficult to earn. However, since it's slightly different from Reversal, I think it should be made a stand-alone gold badge.

It wouldn't make sense to make it a "silver version" of Reversal since a user can get Reversal but not this badge due to the "question later becomes +3" criteria.


So,

Image

The criteria for the badge seems to be a great idea and I think it should be made into a badge.


Firstly, should this be a new badge?

Yes, I don't think that it should replace the existing Reversal badge. Though the flaws of the Reversal badge has been brought up, the idea of the current Reversal badge isn't necessarily bad.

As Tim Post pointed out in this answer,

It's occasionally awarded for someone giving a bit of a snarky answer to a poor question, but most that earn it worked hard for it once they saw an opportunity to get one.

Since the Reversal badge is awarded to the answerer, I don't think that there's anything wrong with occasional bad questions. The main purpose of Reversal is to reward and credit the effort of the answerer who tries to provide a good answer to "not so good" questions.


Secondly, should this be a gold, silver or bronze badge?

The hat of this criteria was the most difficult hat for all 3 Winter Bashes that includes it.

  • In 2014, this was a non-secret hat known as Red Baron and was awarded 26 times.
  • In 2015, this was a secret hat known as Flying Tiger and was awarded 11 times.
  • In 2016, this was a non-secret hat known as Maverick and was awarded 17 times.

So, this concludes that the new badge is quite difficult to earn. However, since it's slightly different from Reversal, I think it should be made a stand-alone gold badge.

It wouldn't make sense to make it a "silver version" of Reversal since a user can get Reversal but not this badge due to the "question later becomes +3" criteria.


So,

Image

1
source | link

The criteria for the badge seems to be a great idea and I think it should be made into a badge.


Firstly, should this be a new badge?

Yes, I don't think that it should replace the existing Reversal badge. Though the flaws of the Reversal badge has been brought up, the idea of the current Reversal badge isn't necessarily bad.

As Tim Post pointed out in this answer,

It's occasionally awarded for someone giving a bit of a snarky answer to a poor question, but most that earn it worked hard for it once they saw an opportunity to get one.

Since the Reversal badge is awarded to the answerer, I don't think that there's anything wrong with occasional bad questions. The main purpose of Reversal is to reward and credit the effort of the answerer who tries to provide a good answer to "not so good" questions.


Secondly, should this be a gold, silver or bronze badge?

The hat of this criteria was the most difficult hat for all 3 Winter Bashes that includes it.

  • In 2014, the hat is known as Red Baron and was awarded 26 times.
  • In 2015, the hat is known as Flying Tiger and was awarded 11 times.
  • In 2016, the hat is known as Maverick and was awarded 17 times.

So, this concludes that the new badge is quite difficult to earn. However, since it's slightly different from Reversal, I think it should be made a stand-alone gold badge.

It wouldn't make sense to make it a "silver version" of Reversal since a user can get Reversal but not this badge due to the "question later becomes +3" criteria.


So,

Image