2 oh, only for unanswered questions (h/t Zanna)
source | link

Here are the guidelines I try to follow, as a high-rep user on some sites and a moderator on others. In all cases I'm talking about questions that seem to be abandoned (OP isn't trying to make them better and it's been a while since the last edit).

  • If a closed question with no good answers is very bad (or almost word-for-word dupe) and the Roomba won't get it, vote to delete. (The Roomba doesn't delete duplicates, nor questions with any upvoted answer.)

  • If a duplicate is bad but has good answers that also work on the original question, pursue a merge (and then delete the dupe). Only mods can merge, so use a custom flag to suggest it. Be sure to review both questions and all answers and say you did so in the flag; it helps.

  • If it's not enough of a dupe for the answers to work there, try to edit the question to make it (a) not bad and (b) still support the existing answers. Bonus points if you can de-dupe it so it can be reopened, but that isn't always possible depending on the answers.

  • At this point, if there are ok answers I tend to just say "meh" and move on, for reasons I'll explain after this bullet point. (I'll vote to delete questions that were obviously going to be closed as off-topic or opinion-based or too broad, even with answers, because the answerers shouldn't be encouraging such questions. But this almost never applies to dupes.)

Note that only logged-in users will see the bad dupe if it has no answers. Go visit aan unanswered dupe in an incognito window where you're not signed in and watch what happens: SE automatically redirects you to the other question. People coming to your site from Google aren't going to see that bad dupe if you close it quickly, but they'll still benefit from its search-engine juice. It's only people with accounts who'll see the question you'd rather people not see.

Here are the guidelines I try to follow, as a high-rep user on some sites and a moderator on others. In all cases I'm talking about questions that seem to be abandoned (OP isn't trying to make them better and it's been a while since the last edit).

  • If a closed question with no good answers is very bad (or almost word-for-word dupe) and the Roomba won't get it, vote to delete. (The Roomba doesn't delete duplicates, nor questions with any upvoted answer.)

  • If a duplicate is bad but has good answers that also work on the original question, pursue a merge (and then delete the dupe). Only mods can merge, so use a custom flag to suggest it. Be sure to review both questions and all answers and say you did so in the flag; it helps.

  • If it's not enough of a dupe for the answers to work there, try to edit the question to make it (a) not bad and (b) still support the existing answers. Bonus points if you can de-dupe it so it can be reopened, but that isn't always possible depending on the answers.

  • At this point, if there are ok answers I tend to just say "meh" and move on, for reasons I'll explain after this bullet point. (I'll vote to delete questions that were obviously going to be closed as off-topic or opinion-based or too broad, even with answers, because the answerers shouldn't be encouraging such questions. But this almost never applies to dupes.)

Note that only logged-in users will see the bad dupe. Go visit a dupe in an incognito window where you're not signed in and watch what happens: SE automatically redirects you to the other question. People coming to your site from Google aren't going to see that bad dupe, but they'll still benefit from its search-engine juice. It's only people with accounts who'll see the question you'd rather people not see.

Here are the guidelines I try to follow, as a high-rep user on some sites and a moderator on others. In all cases I'm talking about questions that seem to be abandoned (OP isn't trying to make them better and it's been a while since the last edit).

  • If a closed question with no good answers is very bad (or almost word-for-word dupe) and the Roomba won't get it, vote to delete. (The Roomba doesn't delete duplicates, nor questions with any upvoted answer.)

  • If a duplicate is bad but has good answers that also work on the original question, pursue a merge (and then delete the dupe). Only mods can merge, so use a custom flag to suggest it. Be sure to review both questions and all answers and say you did so in the flag; it helps.

  • If it's not enough of a dupe for the answers to work there, try to edit the question to make it (a) not bad and (b) still support the existing answers. Bonus points if you can de-dupe it so it can be reopened, but that isn't always possible depending on the answers.

  • At this point, if there are ok answers I tend to just say "meh" and move on, for reasons I'll explain after this bullet point. (I'll vote to delete questions that were obviously going to be closed as off-topic or opinion-based or too broad, even with answers, because the answerers shouldn't be encouraging such questions. But this almost never applies to dupes.)

Note that only logged-in users will see the bad dupe if it has no answers. Go visit an unanswered dupe in an incognito window where you're not signed in and watch what happens: SE automatically redirects you to the other question. People coming to your site from Google aren't going to see that bad dupe if you close it quickly, but they'll still benefit from its search-engine juice. It's only people with accounts who'll see the question you'd rather people not see.

1
source | link

Here are the guidelines I try to follow, as a high-rep user on some sites and a moderator on others. In all cases I'm talking about questions that seem to be abandoned (OP isn't trying to make them better and it's been a while since the last edit).

  • If a closed question with no good answers is very bad (or almost word-for-word dupe) and the Roomba won't get it, vote to delete. (The Roomba doesn't delete duplicates, nor questions with any upvoted answer.)

  • If a duplicate is bad but has good answers that also work on the original question, pursue a merge (and then delete the dupe). Only mods can merge, so use a custom flag to suggest it. Be sure to review both questions and all answers and say you did so in the flag; it helps.

  • If it's not enough of a dupe for the answers to work there, try to edit the question to make it (a) not bad and (b) still support the existing answers. Bonus points if you can de-dupe it so it can be reopened, but that isn't always possible depending on the answers.

  • At this point, if there are ok answers I tend to just say "meh" and move on, for reasons I'll explain after this bullet point. (I'll vote to delete questions that were obviously going to be closed as off-topic or opinion-based or too broad, even with answers, because the answerers shouldn't be encouraging such questions. But this almost never applies to dupes.)

Note that only logged-in users will see the bad dupe. Go visit a dupe in an incognito window where you're not signed in and watch what happens: SE automatically redirects you to the other question. People coming to your site from Google aren't going to see that bad dupe, but they'll still benefit from its search-engine juice. It's only people with accounts who'll see the question you'd rather people not see.