The following query looks into the PostHistory table and searches for the oldest occurrence of the tag. This query runs without problems on a smaller site, such as Mathematics. However, on SO I got timeout on this query. Here is a modified query which returns at least some results on SO - although it runs for a long time, too. (I will also mention that various other tag-related queries can be found in the Tagging chatroom on Mathematics.)
Interestingly, for you the above query did not return the tag bit-fields for which you have the Taxonomist badge and the tag-info says it was created in 2012. SEDE actually returns also some older occurrences of the tag. Maybe som other tags was merged into this tag?
I will add that the above query looks at the actual text of the revision, so it returns also tags which no longer exist - since they have been deleted. (For example, a tag which was created just as a typo will be listed, too.)
Still, this cannot be considered perfectly reliable - for example, the oldest question with some tag might have been deleted in the meantime. And moderators occasionally merge tags - this action changes the tags shown in the revision history.