Skip to main content
Post Closed as "Not suitable for this site" by Infinite Recursion, avpaderno, ᔕᖺᘎᕊ, Fish Below the Ice, CRABOLO
added SO tag, fixed typos, tweaked grammar
Source Link
Pops
  • 69k
  • 34
  • 226
  • 359

I've seen quietquite a few questions about licensing on SO (and asked one myself, yes) and most of them seem to be closed as off-topic or at least frowned aboutupon. So my question is, are they off-topic?

The FAQ states:

... matters that are unique to the programming profession ...

As it seems, software licensing seems to be pretty unique to the programming profession...but but two other points arise as I think about it:

  • It's aThey're legal questionquestions most of the time, but we (at— at least most of us) are nonot lawyers.
  • It yieldsThey have the potential to be subjective, or at least can't be answerednot 100% clinicalanswerable.

So, do I need to close my question as off-topic?

I've seen quiet a few questions about licensing on SO (and asked one myself, yes) and most of them seem to be closed as off-topic or at least frowned about. So my question is, are they off-topic?

The FAQ states:

... matters that are unique to the programming profession ...

As it seems, software licensing seems to be pretty unique to the programming profession...but two other points arise as I think about it:

  • It's a legal question most of the time, but we (at least most of us) are no lawyers.
  • It yields the potential to be subjective, or at least can't be answered 100% clinical.

So, do I need to close my question as off-topic?

I've seen quite a few questions about licensing on SO (and asked one myself, yes) and most of them seem to be closed as off-topic or at least frowned upon. So my question is, are they off-topic?

The FAQ states:

... matters that are unique to the programming profession ...

As it seems, software licensing seems to be pretty unique to the programming profession... but two other points arise as I think about it:

  • They're legal questions most of the time, but we — at least most of us are not lawyers.
  • They have the potential to be subjective, or at least not 100% answerable.

So, do I need to close my question as off-topic?

edited title
Link
Time Traveling Bobby
  • 27.1k
  • 8
  • 66
  • 121

Are licensing questionquestions on- or off-topic on SO?

Source Link
Time Traveling Bobby
  • 27.1k
  • 8
  • 66
  • 121

Are licensing question on- or off-topic on SO?

I've seen quiet a few questions about licensing on SO (and asked one myself, yes) and most of them seem to be closed as off-topic or at least frowned about. So my question is, are they off-topic?

The FAQ states:

... matters that are unique to the programming profession ...

As it seems, software licensing seems to be pretty unique to the programming profession...but two other points arise as I think about it:

  • It's a legal question most of the time, but we (at least most of us) are no lawyers.
  • It yields the potential to be subjective, or at least can't be answered 100% clinical.

So, do I need to close my question as off-topic?