Skip to main content
replaced http://stackoverflow.com/ with https://stackoverflow.com/
Source Link

I was told lately that in somebody opinion "list of something and why" does not belong to SO. Well in my opinion they do but that is up to community to decide so I'm asking:

  1. Do questions of type "please list existing technologies to solve this problem and the reasons why to use/not use some of them" belong to Stack Overflow?
  2. If they do not belong there where to which other SO site they do belong ?
  3. Or they should not asked ?

I was also told that they might belong to programers, but I don't really see the difference between SO and programers (consider this a subquestion). Why was it created ? In my case it just confuses me - I don't know where to put my questions.

Here is the linkHere is the link to the relevant question at SO.

EDIT: Yes, I do think that the question asking for the most fitting technology should be asked with particular problem in mind and that problem should be described there. Or at least some criteria or needs for the technology should be provided (maybe you do not wish to state the problem or you might have needs depending on your skills...).

I was told lately that in somebody opinion "list of something and why" does not belong to SO. Well in my opinion they do but that is up to community to decide so I'm asking:

  1. Do questions of type "please list existing technologies to solve this problem and the reasons why to use/not use some of them" belong to Stack Overflow?
  2. If they do not belong there where to which other SO site they do belong ?
  3. Or they should not asked ?

I was also told that they might belong to programers, but I don't really see the difference between SO and programers (consider this a subquestion). Why was it created ? In my case it just confuses me - I don't know where to put my questions.

Here is the link to the relevant question at SO.

EDIT: Yes, I do think that the question asking for the most fitting technology should be asked with particular problem in mind and that problem should be described there. Or at least some criteria or needs for the technology should be provided (maybe you do not wish to state the problem or you might have needs depending on your skills...).

I was told lately that in somebody opinion "list of something and why" does not belong to SO. Well in my opinion they do but that is up to community to decide so I'm asking:

  1. Do questions of type "please list existing technologies to solve this problem and the reasons why to use/not use some of them" belong to Stack Overflow?
  2. If they do not belong there where to which other SO site they do belong ?
  3. Or they should not asked ?

I was also told that they might belong to programers, but I don't really see the difference between SO and programers (consider this a subquestion). Why was it created ? In my case it just confuses me - I don't know where to put my questions.

Here is the link to the relevant question at SO.

EDIT: Yes, I do think that the question asking for the most fitting technology should be asked with particular problem in mind and that problem should be described there. Or at least some criteria or needs for the technology should be provided (maybe you do not wish to state the problem or you might have needs depending on your skills...).

edited title
Link
avpaderno
  • 67.1k
  • 11
  • 99
  • 225

Does "list Do "list of something and why" questions belong to SO ?? And if not then where ? To which site does my question belong ?

added 2 characters in body
Source Link
John Saunders
  • 15.3k
  • 2
  • 42
  • 84

I was told lately that in somebody opinion "list of something and why" does not belong to SO. Well in my opinion they do but that is up to comunitycommunity to decide so I'm asking:

  1. Do questions of type "please list existing technologies to solve this problem and the reasons why to use/not use some of them" belong to Stack Overflow?
  2. If they do not belong there where to which other SO site they do belong ?
  3. Or they should not asked ?

I was also told that they might belong to programers, but I don't really see the difference between SO and programers (consider this a subquestion). Why was it created ? In my case it just confuses me - I don't know where to put my questions.

Here is the link to the relavantrelevant question at SO.

EDIT: Yes, I do think that the question asking for the most fitting technology should be asked with particular problem in mind and that problem should be described there. Or at least some criteria or needs for the technology should be provided (maybe you do not wish to state the problem or you might have needs depending on your skilsskills...).

I was told lately that in somebody opinion "list of something and why" does not belong to SO. Well in my opinion they do but that is up to comunity to decide so I'm asking:

  1. Do questions of type "please list existing technologies to solve this problem and the reasons why to use/not use some of them" belong to Stack Overflow?
  2. If they do not belong there where to which other SO site they do belong ?
  3. Or they should not asked ?

I was also told that they might belong to programers, but I don't really see the difference between SO and programers (consider this a subquestion). Why was it created ? In my case it just confuses me - I don't know where to put my questions.

Here is the link to the relavant question at SO.

EDIT: Yes, I do think that the question asking for the most fitting technology should be asked with particular problem in mind and that problem should be described there. Or at least some criteria or needs for the technology should be provided (maybe you do not wish to state the problem or you might have needs depending on your skils...).

I was told lately that in somebody opinion "list of something and why" does not belong to SO. Well in my opinion they do but that is up to community to decide so I'm asking:

  1. Do questions of type "please list existing technologies to solve this problem and the reasons why to use/not use some of them" belong to Stack Overflow?
  2. If they do not belong there where to which other SO site they do belong ?
  3. Or they should not asked ?

I was also told that they might belong to programers, but I don't really see the difference between SO and programers (consider this a subquestion). Why was it created ? In my case it just confuses me - I don't know where to put my questions.

Here is the link to the relevant question at SO.

EDIT: Yes, I do think that the question asking for the most fitting technology should be asked with particular problem in mind and that problem should be described there. Or at least some criteria or needs for the technology should be provided (maybe you do not wish to state the problem or you might have needs depending on your skills...).

added 352 characters in body; edited tags
Source Link
Rasto
  • 537
  • 2
  • 8
Loading
link to question added
Source Link
Rasto
  • 537
  • 2
  • 8
Loading
Source Link
Rasto
  • 537
  • 2
  • 8
Loading