I was in the process of answering this question when it got closed underneath me as an exact dup. However, the OP has provided more information this go around, so either it's not an exact dup, or, perhaps better, the other question should be closed and this one left open for the dialogue to complete.
Since neither question is answered yet, I went ahead and opened that one back up and closed the (less detailed) original as a duplicate. Thanks for answering.
Agree. Question closing as an "exact" dup can be sometimes pretty annoying, e.g.
- when the new question is better formulated, brings new facts or arguments,
- when the answers on the old question do not cover the topic well,
- for duplicates of old (+1y) discussions (here on meta), the newly added posts to old discussions don't stand a chance in a lot of highly upvoted ones - so newly put arguments don't stand chance either. New views need new discussions.